Shading from next door's tree: why one quote accounts for it and one doesn't

By Sam Whitfield · October 17, 2026 · 7 min read
Worker installing solar panels on a roof
Photo by Bill Mead on Unsplash

I measured a shadow with a tape measure and a phone compass on a nature strip in Preston a few years back, standing next to a customer who'd already signed one contract and was getting a second opinion before the deposit cleared. Her neighbour's liquidambar threw a shadow across four panels on the north-west corner of her roof for about ninety minutes every winter afternoon. The first installer's quote didn't mention it. The second one had a shading diagram with the tree drawn in, roughly to scale, with a note about restringing that section onto its own optimiser circuit. Same roof, same panel count, two completely different expected outputs. That's the gap I want to talk about, because it's one of the quieter ways a solar quote can be technically accurate and still wrong.

Shading analysis is the bit of a solar quote that's easiest to skip and hardest to notice has been skipped. Nobody circles "no shading assessment performed" on a proposal. It's just absent, and most homeowners don't know to look for it.

Why partial shade does more damage than you'd expect

The physics here trips people up because it feels like it should be proportional. Shade 10% of a panel, lose 10% of its output, right? Not with a standard string inverter system. Panels in a series string behave like a chain: the weakest cell in the chain limits current for the whole string, not just its own output. Shade one cell on one panel and you can drop the output of every panel wired in series with it, not just the shaded one. Bypass diodes claw some of that back by routing current around a shaded section of cells, but they don't eliminate the loss, they just contain it. A single branch shadow crossing a corner of one panel at 3pm in July can cost you meaningfully more than its area would suggest, and if that panel sits mid-string, the whole string suffers until the sun moves on. This is exactly why the DC/AC ratio and clipping conversation installers rarely volunteer matters here too. A string that's already shading-compromised behaves differently under an inverter sized aggressively for clipping. I've written about that interaction in more detail in our piece on DC/AC ratio and inverter clipping, but the short version is that shading and inverter sizing aren't independent decisions. A good designer treats them together.

What a real shading analysis actually looks like

A proper shading assessment isn't a bloke squinting at your roof from the driveway. It should involve a tool that models obstructions against your specific latitude and the sun's path across the full year, not just the day of the site visit. Most reputable installers use something like a Solar Pathfinder or an app-based equivalent that captures a fisheye horizon profile, then overlays sun position data for every month. The output is usually a shading diagram or a percentage loss figure broken down by season. Winter shading from a low sun angle hitting a tree forty metres east of the house is a completely different problem to summer shading from your own roof's parapet. If the quote doesn't separate those, ask why. The honest version of this report often has bad news in it. I've seen assessments come back recommending a homeowner skip two panel positions entirely and rebalance the array elsewhere on the roof, which costs the installer a sale on paper but saves the customer from years of underperformance. That's the sign of someone doing the job properly, not spruiking a bigger number to close the deal.

Micro-inverters and optimisers aren't a shading cure-all

The sales pitch for panel-level power electronics, module-level optimisers or micro-inverters, is usually framed around shading: "each panel works independently, so shade on one doesn't drag down the rest." That's true as far as it goes, and for a roof with a genuinely awkward, permanent shading problem it's often worth the premium. But it's not a substitute for the analysis. A micro-inverter system still loses output on the shaded panel itself, proportional to how much of it is covered. What it stops is the string-wide collapse. If your shading problem is two panels out of twenty, module-level electronics solve a real issue. If your shading problem is that half the roof faces a tree line and gets hit for three hours a day, no amount of per-panel hardware fixes the underlying resource problem. You're just spending more to lose a bit less. I'd argue a lot of optimiser upsells get pitched to roofs that don't actually need them, because it's an easier conversation than telling someone their north-west corner is a bad spot for panels full stop.

Reading a shading report without the jargon

Ask for the shading loss figure as an annual percentage, and ask whether it's already baked into the production estimate on the quote, or sitting as a footnote that nobody's done the maths on. This matters more than people expect, because a quote's headline annual output number is only useful if the inputs behind it are real. The same scepticism applies to roof orientation data. If a company is handwaving the shading assessment, there's a reasonable chance they've also eyeballed your roof's compass bearing rather than measured it properly, and our piece on azimuth versus magnetic north errors covers how a few degrees of sloppy measurement compounds with other sizing mistakes. Tilt angle gets the same treatment far too often too, which I covered separately in the piece on roof tilt angle assumptions most quotes skip. None of these errors are individually catastrophic. Stacked together on one quote, they can shift your real-world output by 15-20% against what's printed on the proposal.

What to do about a tree you don't own

This is the part nobody enjoys. If the shading source is a neighbour's established tree, you generally can't demand they remove it, and council tree protection overlays in a lot of Australian municipalities make that even harder regardless of how much shade it throws. Some councils will consider applications for selective pruning where a tree demonstrably overshadows a solar installation, but the process varies significantly by local government area and isn't guaranteed. The practical move is usually redesigning around the shadow rather than fighting it. That might mean fewer panels on the affected section, module-level electronics just for that string, or accepting a lower output estimate on that part of the roof and making it up elsewhere, including on a north or north-west face that gets full sun for more of the day. It's worth having this conversation before signing anything, not after your first winter bill arrives looking different to the quote.

Checking what's actually gone into your quote

Before you commit, it's reasonable to ask an installer directly whether they ran a formal shading assessment, what tool they used, and whether the production estimate reflects seasonal variation or just a clear-sky assumption. If the answer is vague, that's useful information in itself. Our guide on how many quotes you actually need before signing a solar contract is relevant here too, because a shading discrepancy is exactly the kind of thing that only becomes visible once you've got two proposals side by side for comparison. One quote mentioning a tree and one not mentioning it isn't a coincidence, it's a signal about how carefully each company actually looked at your roof. For the technical background on how shading losses interact with system modelling more broadly, the Clean Energy Council's installer guidelines and the PVsyst documentation both go into the underlying calculation methods installers should be using. On the standards side, the relevant wiring and design requirements for grid-connected solar sit under Clean Energy Council accreditation guidelines, which cover the design competency installers are meant to demonstrate, shading analysis included.

Where this leaves you on sizing

If your roof has any shading at all, even something as minor as a chimney or a neighbouring two-storey extension, the headline kW figure on a quote tells you less than you'd think. Two systems of identical rated capacity, positioned differently on the same roof, can produce noticeably different annual output purely because one designer accounted for the shadow and one didn't. This connects back to the broader sizing conversation too. If you're thinking about future EV charging or a battery addition down the track, a shaded string that's already underperforming is a worse candidate for expansion than a clean, unshaded section of roof, something worth factoring into the kind of forward planning covered in our piece on sizing for a future EV or battery. The tree next door isn't going anywhere soon, in most cases. The least you can do is make sure your quote admits it exists.

— Sam Whitfield, Solar & Batteries, IceWarm

Tagged

Common questions

Can I legally make my neighbour trim a tree that's shading my solar panels?
It depends heavily on your local council's tree protection rules. Many Australian councils have significant tree overlays that protect established trees regardless of the impact on a neighbouring solar system, so legal options are often limited. Some jurisdictions allow applications for selective pruning in specific circumstances, but it's not guaranteed and varies by local government area.
Do micro-inverters fully solve a shading problem?
No. Micro-inverters and optimisers prevent one shaded panel from dragging down the output of an entire string, but the shaded panel itself still loses output proportional to how much shade hits it. They reduce the damage, they don't eliminate the underlying resource loss.
How much output can a small amount of shade actually cost me?
On a standard string inverter system, shading even one cell on one panel can disproportionately reduce output across the whole string it's wired into, because of how series-connected panels share current. The loss is rarely proportional to the shaded area alone.
What should I ask an installer to confirm a shading assessment was done properly?
Ask whether they used a dedicated shading tool that models your specific latitude and roof obstructions across a full year, and whether the annual production estimate on your quote already factors in the seasonal shading loss percentage, rather than assuming clear-sky conditions.
About the author
SW
Sam Whitfield
Solar & batteries · California, US

Sam spent six years installing residential solar before moving to writing full-time, and covers panels, inverters and home batteries.

Former licensed solar installer (C-46, California).

More from Sam Whitfield