Heat Pump vs. Gas Heating: How to Actually Compare Running Costs
Every heat pump brochure has a running-cost comparison chart, and almost none of them tell you what assumptions are baked in. Rather than hand you a number that won't match your bill, here's the actual framework — plug in your own numbers and you'll get a figure you can trust.
The three numbers you need
1. Your gas price, in cents per unit of energy (per kWh-equivalent, or per therm/MJ depending on your market) — check an actual recent bill, not an advertised headline rate, since supply charges and tiered pricing change the effective rate.
2. Your electricity price, in cents per kWh — same caveat, and note whether you're on a flat rate or a time-of-use plan, since a heat pump's hours of operation interact with time-of-use pricing.
3. The efficiency of each system — a gas heater is typically 80–95% efficient (a small fraction of the gas energy is lost as exhaust heat), while a heat pump's effective efficiency is its COP, commonly 300–450% (3.0–4.5) at moderate outdoor temperatures, dropping as it gets colder.
The comparison
Cost per unit of delivered heat = (price per unit of fuel) ÷ (efficiency). For gas, that's roughly your gas price divided by ~0.85–0.9. For a heat pump, it's your electricity price divided by its COP at your typical operating temperature (use the manufacturer's published COP curve for your climate, not the single "nameplate" COP measured at a mild reference temperature).
Because heat pump COP is usually well above 1.0 and gas efficiency is capped near 0.9, a heat pump generally wins on a straight cost-per-unit-of-heat basis almost everywhere electricity isn't priced extremely high relative to gas — but the margin varies enormously by region, and it can narrow or flip in a genuinely cold climate where COP drops toward 2.0, or on a market with unusually cheap piped gas and expensive electricity.
What the brochures leave out
- Standing/supply charges. If switching to a heat pump lets you disconnect gas entirely, you also drop the daily gas supply charge — often a meaningful chunk of a gas bill independent of usage.
- Time-of-use interaction. A heat pump paired with rooftop solar and run mostly during daylight hours (pre-heating water, for example) can cost dramatically less than the same unit run entirely on evening peak electricity rates.
- Sizing and cycling losses. An oversized heat pump that short-cycles (turns on and off frequently rather than running a longer, steadier cycle) loses efficiency in practice versus its rated figures.
Bottom line
Don't trust a single national "heat pumps cost $X/year less than gas" figure — the math is genuinely local. Pull your own gas and electricity rates, use a realistic seasonal COP for your climate (not the optimistic nameplate number), and run the comparison for your specific home before you decide.
Priya covers heat pump heating, cooling and hot water systems — sizing, running costs, and what actually changes between an Australian and a US install.
Mechanical engineering background; ex-HVAC design.
More from Priya Nathan
- The design temperature mistake that skews every heat pump quoteMost heat pump quotes size off the wrong outdoor temperature. Here's why design temperature, not average winter temp, decides if your system actually keeps up.
- The humidity myth that throws off heat pump cooling estimatesHeat pump cooling quotes focus on temperature drop, but humidity removal is the part that actually decides comfort and running cost.
- Why "heat pumps don't work in the cold" is the wrong myth to worry aboutHeat pumps do work in the cold. The real myth is believing minimum operating temperature is the number that matters for your install.
- Vetting a refrigerant handling licence before heat pump work startsBefore a heat pump installer touches refrigerant lines, check their handling licence. Here's what the card actually proves and what it doesn't.
- Why a return-on-investment number for a heat pump rarely survives real lifeMost heat pump payback calculations use one winter's gas price and a brochure COP. Here's why the real payback period almost never matches the quote.
- Vetting a ducted heat pump installer: the warranty registration trapMost heat pump warranties need the installer to register the system within days. Miss that step and the manufacturer owes you nothing.