Why "heat pumps don't work in the cold" is the wrong myth to worry about

By Priya Nathan · November 9, 2026 · 7 min read
Outdoor heat pump unit installation
Photo by alpha innotec on Unsplash

I had a client in the Victorian high country tell me last winter, flat out, that heat pumps "just stop working" below zero. He'd read it on a forum, his neighbour backed it up over the fence, and the quote he'd gotten from a different installer three years earlier had scared him into a wood heater instead. None of that was true in the way he meant it. But I understood exactly why he believed it, because the myth has a kernel of fact buried in it, and that kernel gets mangled every time it gets repeated.

Here's the actual situation: heat pumps work fine in the cold. Modern inverter-driven units with vapour injection or enhanced vapour injection compressors are specified and sold for climates that hit minus 25°C and colder — there are heat pumps running heating duty through Minnesota winters and up in the Canadian prairies right now, today, as I write this. The "doesn't work in the cold" myth isn't really about whether the machine runs. It's a confused version of a real, much narrower problem: capacity shrinks as outdoor temperature drops, and almost nobody sizes for the worst day, they size for an average one. That's the actual story, and it's a sizing and selection story, not a physics-is-broken story.

What the refrigeration cycle actually does below zero

A heat pump moves heat, it doesn't generate it from nothing. In heating mode, the outdoor unit's refrigerant evaporates at a pressure and temperature below ambient, so it can absorb heat from outside air even when that air is cold. The colder the outside air gets, the lower that evaporating temperature needs to sit, which means lower pressure, lower refrigerant density, and less mass flow through the compressor for a given physical size. That's the mechanism behind capacity derating — I've covered the mechanics of why rated capacity shrinks exactly when you need it most in a separate piece, and it's worth reading alongside this one because the two myths are cousins.

What changes the outcome isn't ambient temperature on its own, it's compressor technology. A fixed-speed, single-stage compressor from fifteen years ago genuinely struggled below about -5°C to -10°C, and that's where a lot of the folklore comes from. Today's inverter compressors with enhanced vapour injection (EVI) — sometimes marketed as "hyper-heating" or "cold climate" lines — modulate speed and inject additional refrigerant mid-cycle to maintain head pressure and capacity well past -15°C, with several manufacturers publishing continuous heating curves down to -25°C or lower. The US Department of Energy's cold-climate heat pump technology programme has pushed exactly this shift, and it's the reason heat pumps are now the primary heat source in plenty of genuinely cold US states, not a backup to a furnace.

Where the real problem actually hides

So if the technology handles cold air fine, why do some installs feel like they're struggling on the coldest night of the year? Because the design process skipped a step. Most quotes are built around an average winter temperature or a "typical" design day pulled from a regional table, not the actual coldest sustained snap your specific site sees. I wrote about this exact gap in the design temperature mistake that's quietly costing heat pump owners — it's the single most common sizing error I see in both Australian and US jobs, and it compounds with the derating issue above. Size to an average day, and the system is undersized exactly on the three or four nights a year when you need every watt of it.

The fix isn't a bigger unit across the board — I've also written about why oversizing causes its own problems with short-cycling and comfort swings. The fix is matching the unit's published heating capacity curve against your region's actual 99% or 97.5% design temperature, which for Australian climate zones is published in AS/NZS 1668 and the relevant NatHERS climate files, and for US jobs comes straight out of the ACCA Manual J calculation using ASHRAE design day data. Ask your installer which number they used. If they can't tell you, that's the red flag, not the outdoor temperature itself.

Defrost cycles get blamed for the same myth

There's a second layer to this confusion and it's the defrost cycle. On cold, humid days, frost builds on the outdoor coil and the unit periodically reverses into cooling mode for a few minutes to melt it off, which can push a brief waft of cool air through indoor heads before switching back. I've gone deep on this elsewhere, but it's relevant here because homeowners who notice that cold blast assume it means the unit has given up in the cold. It hasn't — it's doing routine housekeeping, and a well-commissioned system handles it with barely a comfort dip. If your installer never walked you through what defrost looks and sounds like, that's a conversation worth having before the first proper cold snap, not during it.

Backup heat strips are a sizing decision, not a failure admission

A lot of cold-climate installs — especially ducted systems like the Zuba Central Ducted Heat Pump or units such as the Premium Inverter Ducted line — are paired with a small electric resistance backup stage. I'd argue this gets unfairly read as proof the heat pump "can't do it alone." In my view that's backwards. A correctly sized cold-climate heat pump can usually carry the full heating load down to a design temperature well below what most Australian sites ever see, and even in genuinely cold US climates the backup stage is there for the rare extreme outlier day and for redundancy, not because the compressor throws in the towel at -5°C. Think of it the way you'd think of a car's limp-home mode — it exists, you rarely need it, and its presence isn't evidence the engine is weak.

The honest caveat: if your installer has sized the backup stage to carry more than roughly 10-15% of your design heating load, that's usually a sign the heat pump itself was undersized for the job, not a sign backup heat is inherently necessary. Worth asking the installer to show their working on that split.

What actually changes between an Australian and a US cold-climate install

This is where I spend a fair chunk of my working week, comparing specs across markets, and the differences are smaller than people expect but not zero. Australian installs rarely need to spec for anything approaching a genuine cold-climate rating — even alpine towns like Falls Creek or Thredbo sit in a milder band than Minneapolis or Burlington, Vermont. The US market has a much more mature cold-climate category because it has to: NEEP's cold-climate air-source heat pump product list exists specifically because northern states needed a trustworthy way to separate genuine cold-rated units from units that technically run but derate hard below -10°C. If you're in a US northern-tier state, checking whether your shortlisted model is on that NEEP list is more useful than any brochure claim.

In Australia, the more common failure mode isn't extreme cold, it's overnight radiative cooling in places like the Southern Tablelands or western Victoria, where you get surprisingly sharp single-digit negative snaps despite a mild average climate. Installers sizing off capital-city averages miss these pockets regularly.

What I'd actually check before signing

Ask for the manufacturer's heating capacity curve at your region's design temperature, not just the headline rated capacity at 7°C that sits on the box — I've written separately about why that box number isn't the COP you'll actually get. Ask whether the quote used your postcode's actual design day or a regional default. And if you're anywhere near a US cold-climate zone, check the NEEP list before the brochure. None of this requires distrusting the technology. The refrigeration cycle genuinely does work down to serious cold on the right equipment. The myth worth killing isn't "heat pumps fail in the cold" — it's "the standard sizing process accounts for your coldest night." Usually it doesn't, until you make it.

My client in the high country, by the way, ended up with a correctly sized EVI ducted system and a small backup strip he's used maybe twice in two winters. He still mentions the forum post sometimes. Fair enough — it took one proper cold snap to convince him, and that's probably the only argument that ever really lands.

Tagged

Common questions

Do heat pumps actually stop working in freezing temperatures?
No. Modern inverter heat pumps with vapour injection compressors are rated for continuous heating well below -15°C, and some cold-climate models are tested to -25°C or lower. Older fixed-speed units struggled around -5°C to -10°C, which is where most of this myth originated.
Why does my heat pump's heating capacity drop when it's cold outside?
It's a refrigeration cycle effect, not a fault. Colder outdoor air forces a lower evaporating temperature and pressure, which reduces refrigerant mass flow and available capacity. This is normal and is accounted for in a properly sized system's design calculations.
How do I know if a heat pump is genuinely rated for cold climates?
Check the manufacturer's published heating capacity curve at low temperatures, not just the headline rating at 7°C. In the US, NEEP maintains a cold-climate air-source heat pump product list specifically for this comparison.
Is backup electric heat a sign the heat pump is undersized?
Not necessarily. A small backup stage for rare extreme days and redundancy is normal, even on well-sized systems. If backup is carrying more than about 10-15% of the design heating load, that's a sign the heat pump itself may have been undersized.
About the author
PN
Priya Nathan
Heat pumps & HVAC · Melbourne, AU

Priya covers heat pump heating, cooling and hot water systems — sizing, running costs, and what actually changes between an Australian and a US install.

Mechanical engineering background; ex-HVAC design.

More from Priya Nathan