Why your NatHERS star rating can change without touching the house
I had a builder ring me last month, genuinely rattled, because the same house plan came back with a 6.4 star rating from one assessor and a 7.1 from another. Nothing had changed. Same drawings, same block, same insulation spec. He assumed someone had made an error. Nobody had. This happens more often than the industry likes to admit, and understanding why is the difference between trusting your rating and quietly resenting it.
A NatHERS star rating feels like a fixed fact about a house, printed on a certificate, filed with council, done. It isn't. It's a modelled output from a specific set of inputs run through accredited software on a specific day, referencing a specific climate zone file. Change any one of those inputs, even slightly, and the number moves. I've seen half-star swings from things that have nothing to do with the physical building at all.
The rating is a simulation, not a measurement
This is the part people skip past. NatHERS doesn't measure your house — nobody comes with a thermal camera and clocks how it actually performs in July. The assessor builds a 3D model of the dwelling in accredited software (AccuRate, BERS Pro or FirstRate5 are the common ones) using the architectural drawings, then the software runs simulated hourly weather data for your climate zone across a full year and calculates the heating and cooling energy the model would need to stay within a comfort band.
That's a genuinely useful abstraction. It lets you compare a house in Wagga to one in Wollongong on a like-for-like basis. But it also means the star rating is only as good as the model, and the model is only as good as the inputs the assessor was given and the assumptions baked into that particular software build. The Nationwide House Energy Rating Scheme is administered nationally but the tools themselves get updated periodically, and each update can shift outputs slightly even on an identical house.
Orientation and site data move the number more than most owners expect
Rotate a house 45 degrees on the same block and the star rating can shift by half a star or more, purely from solar exposure through the glazing. This is well understood by anyone who's read our piece on double vs triple glazing, where orientation and window placement do more work than glass spec alone. What surprises people is how sensitive the model is to small orientation errors on the plans themselves.
If the assessor is working from a site plan where true north is drawn 10-15 degrees off, or the eave overhang length on a north-facing window is measured slightly generous, the simulated solar gain changes and so does the rating. I've seen certificates redone after a surveyor corrected the boundary orientation, and the star rating moved by a third of a star without a single wall being touched. It's not fraud, it's just the sensitivity of the tool. This is exactly why the on-site check matters, which is covered properly in what a NatHERS or HERS assessor actually checks on-site — the assessor verifying real dimensions against the plan is often where these discrepancies get caught, or missed.
Software version and climate file updates change historical ratings
Here's the one that actually annoys people once they understand it: the accredited software packages get periodically updated with revised climate data, revised default assumptions, or corrected calculation methods. When that happens, a house rated 7 stars under an older software version might model differently under the current version, even though nothing in the build changed.
This is why a rating certificate has an effective date and references a specific software version and protocol. It's not meant to be re-run indefinitely and treated as gospel five years later. If you're doing a renovation and pulling an old certificate to extend from, expect your assessor to re-run the whole model rather than just bolt an addition onto the old numbers. The CSIRO-administered NatHERS technical protocols exist precisely to keep this process auditable, and the NatHERS national administrator's site publishes the current software accreditation list if you want to check which tool your assessor used.
Default assumptions fill gaps you didn't know existed
Assessors don't always have complete information. If ceiling insulation thickness isn't specified on drawings, or a skylight shaft construction isn't detailed, the software applies a default value from the relevant Building Code of Australia deemed-to-satisfy provisions or a conservative fallback. Those defaults are sensible in isolation but they compound.
I reckon this is the single biggest source of rating disputes on project homes. A volume builder's standard plan gets rated once with generic defaults, then the actual house gets built with upgraded glazing or extra insulation that never makes it back into the model. The certificate technically matches what was submitted, not what got built. This is one reason I tell people to ask pointed questions before signing anything — our guide on questions to ask an insulation or green-building contractor covers exactly this gap between spec and installation.
Air leakage is mostly assumed, not tested
Unlike some overseas rating schemes, standard NatHERS assessments generally don't require a blower door test to measure actual air leakage — infiltration rates are typically assumed based on construction type and sealing details described on the drawings, not verified in the field. That means two houses built to identical plans but with wildly different site workmanship, one with taped sarking and sealed penetrations, one with gaps around every downlight, can carry the same star rating on paper while performing quite differently in practice.
This is a genuine gap in the scheme, in my opinion, and it's the reason the order of construction operations matters so much. If you want the modelled rating to reflect something close to real performance, the air sealing has to actually happen the way it's drawn, which is the whole argument in our piece on air sealing before insulation. The rating rewards good sealing on paper. It doesn't verify it happened.
What this means if you're comparing two certificates
If you're staring at two star ratings for what looks like the same house and trying to work out which one to trust, check four things before assuming either is wrong: the software name and version listed on each certificate, the climate zone file referenced, whether the orientation on the site plan matches the actual boundary survey, and whether the insulation and glazing specs on the model match what's actually specified in the contract documents, not just the display home brochure.
A rating done six months apart under different software versions isn't comparing like with like, and that's worth knowing before you argue with a builder or an assessor about a discrepancy that might just be a protocol update. Worth noting too, for anyone building near the US and comparing schemes, that HERS in the States works on a different scoring logic entirely — we've laid out the practical differences in NatHERS vs HERS: how Australian and US home energy ratings compare.
None of this means the star rating is meaningless. It's still the best standardised comparison tool we have for thermal performance in a new build, and for most homes it correlates reasonably well with how the house actually feels to live in, particularly once you've also sorted the mechanical systems that do the rest of the work — see our heat pump coverage for the load side of that equation. But treat the number as a well-informed estimate from a specific model run, not an immutable fact stamped onto the bricks. Ask what software and version was used, check the orientation against the real site, and if you're extending an older home, expect the number to move when it gets re-run. It usually should.
Common questions
- Can two NatHERS assessors give the same house different star ratings?
- Yes, and it doesn't necessarily mean either one is wrong. Small differences in orientation data, insulation defaults, or the software version used can shift the modelled result by half a star or more on an identical plan.
- Does a NatHERS rating measure how airtight my house actually is?
- Not directly. Standard assessments generally assume an infiltration rate based on construction type and sealing details shown on the drawings, rather than testing actual air leakage on site with a blower door.
- Why would my star rating change if I re-run an old certificate?
- NatHERS-accredited software packages and climate data get updated periodically. A certificate has an effective date tied to a specific software version, and re-running the same house under a newer version can produce a different number even with no physical changes.
- Does the assessor check that the house was actually built to the rated specification?
- Not always in full. The rating reflects what was submitted on the plans and specifications at assessment time. If upgrades or downgrades happen during construction without updating the model, the certificate and the built house can diverge.
Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.
Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).
More from Ben Sorensen
- Why a NatHERS or HERS rating can change without touching the buildA NatHERS or HERS rating can shift star bands when software updates, climate files get revised, or rules change — even if your house hasn't.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating ignores your floor coveringsCarpet, tile and polished concrete all score the same in a NatHERS or HERS model, even though they feel wildly different underfoot and change how your heating actually performs.
- Vetting an insulation installer: the R-value receipt nobody asks forInsulation installers rarely need a specific trade licence, which is exactly why the paperwork trail matters more than the handshake.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never touches your thermal bridgesA NatHERS or HERS rating models your walls as flat layers, which means steel studs, balcony slabs and window reveals rarely get the credit (or blame) they deserve.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never checks your orientation on siteYour NatHERS or HERS star rating locks in orientation at design stage, but nobody re-checks it once the slab is poured the wrong way round.
- Vetting a window glazier for new-build glazing: what to checkBefore a glazier touches your new-build windows, check the licence, the AS 2047 compliance paperwork and the install method. Here's what actually matters.