Why a NatHERS or HERS rating can change without touching the build

By Ben Sorensen · November 20, 2026 · 7 min read
Modern energy-efficient home exterior
Photo by Naksha Banwao on Unsplash

I had a client email me last year, genuinely rattled, because she'd re-run a rating on a house she'd owned for six years and gotten a different number. Nothing had been touched. No renovation, no new windows, no insulation top-up. Same house, same orientation, same everything — and the star band had moved. She thought the assessor had made an error. He hadn't. This happens more often than most homeowners realise, and almost nobody explains it before it catches people off guard.

A NatHERS or HERS rating isn't a fixed physical measurement like a tape measure against a wall. It's a modelled output from a piece of software, run against a climate file, scored against a methodology — and every one of those three things gets revised periodically. The house sits still. The yardstick moves.

The software behind the number isn't static

In Australia, NatHERS accreditation runs through a small number of approved simulation engines — AccuRate and similar tools — and the Clean Energy Regulator-adjacent body overseeing the scheme periodically pushes updates to the calculation engine itself. In the US, HERS ratings run through RESNET-accredited software using the HERS Index methodology, which has also been revised over the programme's history as reference homes and baseline assumptions get updated.

When an engine update ships, it can change how the software weighs things like air leakage, glazing performance, or zone-by-zone heat flow — not because your house changed, but because the model got more precise, or because a bug got fixed, or because a new building science input got folded in. I've seen identical floor plans rated two stars apart purely because one assessment used an older engine version and the other used the current one. Neither assessor did anything wrong. They used what was current at the time.

This is part of why I keep telling people a rating is a snapshot, not a certificate that ages gracefully. If you want the full picture on what a rating actually represents rather than guarantees, I've gone deeper on that distinction in why your NatHERS or HERS rating is a design tool, not a build receipt.

Climate files get revised too

Every rating is run against a reference climate file for your specific zone — a stitched-together dataset built from decades of weather station records for that region. These files aren't eternal. They get refreshed periodically as more recent weather data comes in, and when a region's climate file shifts (more extreme summer days recorded, a slightly different average winter minimum), the cooling and heating loads calculated for an identical house in that zone shift with it.

I covered how these climate assumptions work in more detail in what a NatHERS or HERS rating actually assumes about your climate file, but the short version for this piece: your house didn't get hotter or colder. The reference dataset describing your climate zone got updated to reflect what's actually been observed. That's a reasonable thing for the scheme to do — it's just invisible to a homeowner comparing an old certificate to a new one.

Methodology and star-banding rules move on their own timeline

Separate from software and climate files, the rules for what counts as a "6 star" or "7 star" outcome periodically get revised by the bodies running each scheme. In Australia that's shaped by the National Construction Code cycle and state-based minimum requirements layered on top of it; in the US, RESNET periodically updates the HERS Index reference home definition. When the reference home used as the baseline for comparison changes, every rated house's relative score shifts too, even with zero physical change.

This is the part that trips people up most. A 6-star rating issued under one NCC cycle isn't automatically a 6-star rating under the next one, because "6 stars" is a relative position against a moving reference point, not an absolute physical performance threshold. I'd argue this is honestly a reasonable design choice for the scheme — building science should improve over time and the bar should move with it — but it's a lousy experience for a homeowner who assumed their certificate was a permanent fact about their house.

What this means if you're buying a resale property

If you're relying on an older NatHERS or HERS certificate when buying a resale home, treat the star number as context, not gospel. A certificate issued eight years ago under an earlier software version and an earlier climate file isn't directly comparable to one issued last month on a different property down the street, even if both show "6 stars" on the paperwork.

I had a look through a resale listing near Beach Road last winter where the vendor was waving around a decade-old 7-star certificate like it settled the matter. It didn't tell you anything about the actual window install quality, the ductwork condition, or whether insulation had settled in the ceiling since. For that kind of forensic detail you want someone doing a blower door test and thermal imaging on the actual building fabric as it stands today, not relying on a historic number. We've written about vetting a blower door and thermal imaging auditor for exactly this situation — it's the tool that catches what a dated certificate can't.

It's also worth remembering the certificate never carried R-values or bill estimates in the first place, so there's nothing granular being "lost" when the methodology shifts. I went through why the certificate is deliberately thin on that kind of detail in why your NatHERS or HERS certificate doesn't list a single R-value.

Why re-rating isn't usually worth chasing

Homeowners sometimes ask whether they should pay for a fresh rating just to see where they land under the current software and climate file. My honest answer, most of the time, is no. A rating exists to inform design decisions, satisfy a planning or building permit requirement, or support a sale disclosure obligation — not to track your house's standing against a shifting scale for its own sake.

The exception is if you're planning a renovation that will trigger a compliance pathway requiring a rating anyway, or you're selling and want current, defensible paperwork rather than something that might raise eyebrows for being out of date. In those cases, yes, get it re-run with current tools. Otherwise, your energy is better spent on the physical things that actually move comfort and running costs regardless of what star band is in fashion this NCC cycle: air sealing, insulation continuity, glazing performance, and orientation-aware shading.

If you're weighing up whether a renovation is worth a formal reassessment, it's also worth separating the rating question from the practical install quality question. A rating can shift on paperwork grounds while your actual insulation installation never gets inspected at all — I've written about that gap specifically in does a NatHERS or HERS rating ever check your insulation installation?

What actually stays stable

The physical building envelope doesn't care which software version or climate file was current the week your rating was issued. Continuous insulation, well-sealed penetrations, correctly installed double glazing, and shading that matches your actual orientation all perform the same regardless of which star number is printed on a certificate from any given year. That consistency is the real asset — the certificate is just one dated reading of it.

When I'm on site with a builder, I spend far more time looking at junction details and air sealing than I do worrying about whether a design modelled at 6.8 stars three years ago would still model at 6.8 today. According to the Australian Government's YourHome guide on building for climate (a Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water resource), the fundamentals of good passive design — orientation, thermal mass placement, shading — remain the stable foundation under any rating methodology that comes after. RESNET's own published documentation on the HERS Index makes a similar point about the US context: the index measures relative performance against a reference home, and that reference definition is reviewed periodically as building codes and typical construction practice evolve.

A quick gut-check for your own certificate

If you're holding a certificate right now and wondering whether it's still meaningful, check the issue date against your local code cycle. In Australia, cross-reference it against the current NCC cycle in force for your state. In the US, check whether your state's adopted energy code references a recent HERS reference home update. If your certificate predates the most recent cycle by more than a few years, treat the star number as indicative rather than current, and lean on a physical inspection if the number genuinely matters for a transaction.

None of this is cause for alarm. It's just a reminder that a star rating is a position on a ruler that occasionally gets re-marked, not a fixed measurement of your walls. The walls, thankfully, are still exactly where you left them.

— Ben Sorensen, Green Building, IceWarm

Tagged

Common questions

Can my NatHERS or HERS star rating change without any renovation?
Yes. Updates to the accredited simulation software, revised regional climate files, or changes to the reference home methodology can all shift the star band for an unchanged physical house.
Should I get my house re-rated just to see if the number changed?
Usually not, unless you're renovating in a way that triggers a compliance pathway or selling and want current paperwork. The physical building fabric matters more than chasing a moving reference scale.
How often does the reference methodology actually get updated?
It tracks each jurisdiction's building code cycle and the scheme administrator's software release schedule, roughly every few years rather than annually, but there's no fixed universal interval.
Does an older certificate mean the house performs worse than a newer one with the same star rating?
Not necessarily. It means the two certificates were scored against different baselines, so the numbers aren't directly comparable without checking what methodology and climate file each one used.
About the author
BS
Ben Sorensen
Green building · Perth, AU

Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.

Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).

More from Ben Sorensen