Can you get a 7-star NatHERS rating and still freeze in July?

By Ben Sorensen · August 4, 2026 · 7 min read
Modern energy-efficient house exterior
Photo by Naksha Banwao on Unsplash

I got a call last winter from a client in the Adelaide Hills who'd built to a 7.5-star NatHERS rating two years earlier. Good architect, decent budget, a build that should have been a case study. Her question was blunt: "why is my living room still cold at 7am in July if the software says this house is efficient?" It's a fair question, and it comes up more than you'd think once people move past the certificate and into actually living in the place.

The short answer is that a star rating and a comfort outcome are related but not the same thing. A high number is necessary but not sufficient. I've walked through enough of these houses now, thermal camera in hand, to know exactly where the gap tends to open up, and it's rarely where owners expect.

What a star rating is actually modelling

NatHERS (and HERS in the US, though the mechanics differ, as I've covered in our NatHERS vs HERS comparison) models annual heating and cooling energy load under a standardised simulated climate year, standardised occupancy assumptions, and a fixed indoor temperature band. It is, at its core, an energy-demand estimate, not a comfort guarantee. The software (AccuRate or FirstRate5 in Australia's case) takes your building envelope, orientation, glazing schedule, insulation values and construction mass, and predicts how much energy a hypothetical heating and cooling system would need to hold the house within that band across the year.

That's a genuinely useful number for comparing designs. It's a poor proxy for "will I be cold in bed on the coldest morning of the year", because the standardised occupancy pattern assumes things about when rooms are heated, how doors are used, and how people actually behave that rarely match reality. The assessment also averages performance across the whole dwelling. A house can post a strong overall rating while one bedroom, typically the one furthest from the living zone or facing due south, sits well outside the comfort band the rest of the home enjoys.

Where the mismatch usually starts: zoning the software doesn't see

NatHERS models the building envelope as a set of thermal zones, but it doesn't know how you'll actually use those zones. A rating doesn't penalise a house for having a heated living room and an unheated bedroom wing, because the software assumes reasonable, whole-house conditioning by default in its energy calculation. In practice, plenty of owners heat the living areas and let bedrooms drift, either through habit or because the ducted system was value-engineered down to fewer zones than the design called for.

This is the single biggest gap I see on site visits. The certificate says 7 stars. The lived experience is "the study is always freezing." Both can be true, because the rating is an aggregate and comfort is a room-by-room experience. If you're renovating or building, ask your designer for the room-by-room heating and cooling loads behind the headline number, not just the star figure. Most assessors can pull that from the software; most homeowners never think to ask.

Thermal mass and orientation: modelled correctly, lived differently

Thermal mass is where I see the second-biggest gap. NatHERS models mass, concrete slabs, masonry walls, as a moderating influence on internal temperature swings, and it's right to do so in principle. But mass only helps if it's charged and discharged on the right cycle. A slab that gets direct winter sun through north glazing and releases that heat overnight is doing real work. The same slab under a verandah that blocks winter sun, or facing east where morning sun is brief, is just thermal deadweight, present in the model, contributing very little in reality.

I've seen designs where the modelled orientation on paper didn't match the as-built orientation because of a site survey error or a late design change that never got re-run through the software. The star rating on the certificate reflected the original design. The house that got built was subtly different, and subtly worse for it. This is exactly the kind of thing that shows up in why your NatHERS star rating can change without touching the house — the physical building can be identical to spec and still perform differently to the paperwork if the modelling inputs drifted.

Air leakage: the variable most ratings still estimate rather than measure

Air leakage is the other quiet gap. Historically, NatHERS assessments used a default air leakage assumption rather than a measured blower-door result, though this has been tightening with recent protocol updates and is increasingly common as a verified input on higher-performance builds. A default assumption is a reasonable average, but averages hide outliers. A house with poor detailing around penetrations, downlights, and the wall-ceiling junction can leak two or three times the assumed rate and post the same star rating as a tightly sealed build, right up until someone actually tests it.

This matters because air leakage doesn't just waste energy, it directly drives the draughts and cold-radiant-surface feeling that people describe as "the house doesn't feel as good as the rating suggested." I've written before about why air sealing needs to happen before insulation goes in, and this is the practical consequence: get a blower-door test done regardless of whether your rating pathway required one. It's a relatively small spend against a full build budget and it tells you something the star rating, on its own, cannot.

Glazing performance: modelled U-values versus installed reality

Windows are input into NatHERS using U-value and SHGC figures from the National Fenestration Rating Council-style testing or, in Australia, WERS ratings via the Australian Window Association. Those figures assume correct installation: proper flashing, sealed reveals, thermally broken frames fitted as specified. An installer who substitutes a cheaper frame system mid-build, or who leaves gaps around the frame that get filled with expanding foam rather than a proper air-seal detail, can quietly erode the performance the assessor modelled without changing the certificate at all, because certificates aren't usually re-run after installation.

This is one of the reasons I keep pushing people toward vetting the installer as carefully as the product spec. Our guide on vetting a window and glazing installer goes into the certifications and red flags worth checking before you sign, and it's just as relevant whether you've chosen double or triple glazing, a decision covered in more depth in double vs triple glazing: when the extra pane is worth it.

What assessors actually check, and what falls outside their scope

I've covered the mechanics of a site assessment before in what a NatHERS or HERS assessor actually checks on-site, so I won't repeat all of it here. But the short version relevant to this comfort gap: an assessor is verifying that what's built matches what's modelled, insulation levels, glazing specs, orientation, floor area. They are not, in a standard assessment, running a blower-door test, checking duct sealing quality, or verifying zone-by-zone conditioning strategy. Those things sit adjacent to the rating, not inside it, and in my view that's a genuine limitation of the framework as it currently operates in most jurisdictions, not a criticism of individual assessors doing their job to the letter of the protocol.

The Nationwide House Energy Rating Scheme publishes its technical documentation through the federal Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water, and it's worth a homeowner's time to read the scope statement rather than assume the certificate is a full comfort audit. It isn't designed to be one, and treating it as one is where expectations and lived experience part ways.

What to actually check if comfort is the goal

If you're building or renovating and comfort, not just the certificate, is what you're after, a few things are worth doing beyond hitting a star target. Ask for room-by-room load calculations, not just the whole-house average. Get a blower-door test even if your pathway doesn't mandate one; it typically costs a fraction of what a heating system upgrade would cost later. Confirm your HVAC contractor is sizing to the actual room loads rather than a rule-of-thumb per-square-metre figure, because an oversized heat pump creates its own comfort problems even in a well-rated house. And walk the glazing installation yourself, or have someone who knows what a proper seal looks like walk it for you, before the linings go up and you can't see the detail anymore.

None of this makes the star rating useless. It's still the best single comparative number we have for design decisions, and a 7-star house genuinely uses less energy than a 4-star one, on average, over a year. But average annual energy demand and "is this room comfortable on the coldest morning" are two different questions, and my Adelaide Hills client's cold living room was answered by fixing zoning and a duct leak, not by re-running the software.

— Ben Sorensen, Green Building Writer

Tagged

Common questions

Does a higher NatHERS or HERS star rating guarantee a more comfortable house?
Not on its own. It guarantees lower modelled annual heating and cooling energy demand under standardised assumptions. Comfort in individual rooms depends on zoning, air sealing quality, thermal mass placement and installation detail, none of which the star rating fully captures.
Why would one room in a high-rated house feel cold when the rest of the house is fine?
Star ratings are usually reported as a whole-house average. A poorly zoned HVAC system, a room with unfavourable orientation, or a local air leak can leave one space performing well below the average even in a strong overall rating.
Should I get a blower-door test even if my rating pathway didn't require one?
Yes, it's worth the modest cost. Many rating assessments still use a default air leakage assumption rather than a measured figure, so an actual blower-door test tells you something the certificate alone doesn't.
Can the star rating change if nothing about the house physically changes?
Yes, this can happen due to software version updates, climate file changes, or modelling input corrections. It's covered in more detail in our article on why NatHERS ratings can shift without renovation.
About the author
BS
Ben Sorensen
Green building · Perth, AU

Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.

Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).

More from Ben Sorensen