The circuit sizing mistake that trips heat pump installs before day one
I got a call last month from a homeowner on Bellarine Highway near Ocean Grove who'd already picked her heat pump, already got a glowing quote from a mate's cousin who "does aircon," and was two days from install when the electrician showed up, looked at the switchboard, and said no. Not "let's talk about it" no. Flat no. The board was full, the existing run to that side of the house was a 2.5mm cable on a shared circuit with the kitchen, and the new outdoor unit needed its own dedicated run rated for a fair bit more current than what was sitting there. She'd spent weeks comparing COP figures and decibel ratings. Nobody had mentioned the panel.
This is the part of a heat pump install that almost never makes it into the sales conversation, and it's costing homeowners real money and real delays. Everyone obsesses over sizing the unit to the room — and fair enough, that matters, I've written plenty about why oversizing quietly ruins comfort and running costs — but circuit sizing is a completely separate calculation, and it's the one that decides whether your install happens on schedule, needs an expensive board upgrade, or gets red-tagged by an inspector after the fact.
Why the unit's amp draw isn't the number you design around
Every heat pump has a rated running current on its nameplate, and a lot of homeowners assume that's the number the electrician sizes the circuit to. It isn't, or at least not directly. Compressors draw a locked-rotor current on startup that's several times higher than steady-state running current — sometimes five to six times higher for a second or two while the compressor rotor gets moving against static refrigerant pressure. Circuit breakers, cable gauge and any shared-load calculations all need to account for that startup surge, not just the number the unit draws once it's cycling normally.
In the US this is where the National Electrical Code's minimum circuit ampacity (MCA) and maximum overcurrent protection (MOCP) figures come in — both printed on the equipment nameplate, both mandatory reference points for the installing electrician under NEC Article 440 for motor-driven and hermetic refrigerant compressor equipment. In Australia the equivalent discipline sits under AS/NZS 3000 wiring rules, with the compressor's starting characteristics and any inrush current limiting device factored into the circuit design rather than eyeballed off the running-amp figure on the box. Neither system lets an installer just read "13 amps" off the spec sheet and pick a 15-amp breaker and call it done.
The switchboard capacity problem nobody quotes for
Here's the bit that actually derails installs. It's not usually the new circuit itself that's the problem — it's whether the existing switchboard or panel has spare capacity to add it. A lot of homes built before the 2000s, in both Australia and the US, were fitted with boards sized for the electrical loads of their era: lighting, a few power points, maybe ducted gas heating that barely touched the electrical system at all. Add a heat pump for space heating, another for hot water, maybe an EV charger down the track, and you're asking a board designed for a fraction of that load to carry it. This is exactly the same blind spot I see in EV charger installs — I covered the amperage and circuit sizing question in detail in EV charger amperage and circuit sizing, and the switchboard capacity issue is near-identical for a heat pump. The fix is sometimes a straightforward new dedicated circuit off existing spare capacity. Sometimes it's a full board upgrade, which on an older property can run into serious money and add weeks to a project timeline nobody budgeted for.
I'll be blunt: I think most heat pump sales conversations skip this deliberately, not through malice but because it complicates the pitch. Nobody wants to tell a homeowner mid-quote that their $4,000 heat pump might need a $2,500 switchboard upgrade to actually get installed. But leaving it out doesn't make the problem go away — it just moves the bad news to install day, which is the worst possible time to discover it.
Dedicated circuits, shared circuits, and why it matters more for ducted systems
A single split-system head drawing modest current might, in some jurisdictions and on some boards, share headroom more comfortably than people assume — though a dedicated circuit is still standard practice almost everywhere for anything beyond a small unit. Where it gets genuinely non-negotiable is ducted systems and multi-head arrangements, where total system draw adds up fast and a shared or undersized circuit becomes a nuisance-tripping problem at best and a fire risk at worst.
If you're comparing ducted vs split-system heat pumps for your place, the circuit question is one more thing tipping the scales — ducted systems generally mean a heavier, dedicated circuit and sometimes a three-phase supply conversation in bigger homes, whereas a single well-placed split system might sit more easily on an existing board. It's not a reason to avoid ducted, but it's a cost line that belongs in the initial quote, not discovered afterward.
Hot water heat pumps add their own wrinkle. A unit like the ProTerra Hot Water Heat Pump or the Voltex MAX Hybrid Electric Heat Pump Water Heater often needs its own dedicated circuit separate from the old electric resistance tank it's replacing, because the compressor and backup element combination draws differently than a straight resistance element did. If your electrician is simply reusing the old hot water circuit without checking the new unit's nameplate figures, that's a red flag worth asking about directly.
What to actually ask before you sign a quote
The practical fix here isn't complicated, it just requires asking the right question before deposit day rather than after. Ask whoever is quoting the install two things: what's the minimum circuit ampacity and maximum breaker size for this specific unit, and has anyone actually opened the switchboard to check spare capacity and existing cable gauge on the run it'll use. If the answer to either is vague — "should be fine" is not an answer — that's your signal to get a licensed electrician to do a proper assessment before committing to install dates.
This is also where I'd push back gently on the idea that any electrician can do this work interchangeably. Refrigerant-side commissioning and electrical circuit work are two different licensing regimes, and the refrigerant handling licence check matters just as much as the electrical one — you want documented evidence both sides were done by someone qualified, not just a verbal assurance. Ask for the commissioning certificate at handover, and if a switchboard upgrade was part of the job, get that documented separately too, since it's the kind of work an insurer or future buyer's inspector will ask about.
Load calculations aren't just for the heat pump itself
There's a broader point here that connects back to something I've banged on about before: proper sizing starts with a load calculation, not a gross estimate — see my piece on Manual J and why load calcs still get skipped. But the electrical side needs its own version of that discipline. If you're adding a heat pump for heating, a heat pump hot water unit, and eyeing an EV charger in the next two years, the smart move is getting the electrician to assess total future electrical demand now, not sequentially as each appliance shows up. Sequential upgrades to the same board cost more in aggregate than one properly planned upgrade, and I've seen homeowners pay for three separate callout fees over eighteen months when one conversation up front would've covered it.
The US Department of Energy's guidance on electrification-ready homes points the same direction — plan panel capacity around where the home's total electric load is heading, not just the single appliance in front of you today. If you're weighing running costs across heating options generally, it's worth reading alongside how to actually compare heat pump versus gas running costs, because a board upgrade is a real cost that belongs in that comparison, not an externality you discover after the fact.
Back to Ocean Grove
That homeowner near Bellarine Highway ended up getting the board upgrade done — it added about ten days and a few thousand dollars she hadn't planned for, and she was annoyed, fairly, that nobody flagged it during quoting. The heat pump itself has run fine since. The lesson wasn't about the equipment at all. It was that the electrical assessment needed to happen before the unit was chosen, not after, and that's a sequencing mistake I still see homeowners make even when they've done everything else right — comparing COP, checking the heat pump options properly, reading up on cold-climate performance. The switchboard doesn't care how good your research was if nobody opened the door and looked inside it.
Common questions
- Does every heat pump need its own dedicated electrical circuit?
- Ducted systems and most multi-head setups almost always need a dedicated circuit because total compressor draw adds up fast. A single small split-system head sometimes shares more comfortably on an existing board, but a dedicated circuit is still standard practice in most jurisdictions and it's what a licensed electrician will typically recommend regardless of unit size.
- How do I find out if my switchboard has spare capacity before I quote a heat pump?
- Ask a licensed electrician to physically open the board and assess spare capacity, existing cable gauge on the intended run, and total connected load, rather than relying on a verbal estimate from whoever is quoting the heat pump itself. This should happen before you commit to a unit, not after.
- What's the difference between MCA and the running amps on a heat pump nameplate?
- Running amps is the steady-state current draw once the compressor is cycling normally. Minimum circuit ampacity (MCA) accounts for the much higher startup surge current a compressor draws for a second or two on startup, and it's the figure electricians use under NEC Article 440 in the US, or the equivalent inrush-current provisions under AS/NZS 3000 in Australia, to size the actual circuit and breaker.
- Can a switchboard upgrade for a heat pump be planned alongside a future EV charger?
- Yes, and it's usually cheaper to do it that way. Getting an electrician to assess total future electrical demand — heat pump, hot water heat pump, EV charger — in one visit avoids paying for multiple separate callouts and board modifications as each appliance gets added over time.
Priya covers heat pump heating, cooling and hot water systems — sizing, running costs, and what actually changes between an Australian and a US install.
Mechanical engineering background; ex-HVAC design.
More from Priya Nathan
- The design temperature mistake that skews every heat pump quoteMost heat pump quotes size off the wrong outdoor temperature. Here's why design temperature, not average winter temp, decides if your system actually keeps up.
- The humidity myth that throws off heat pump cooling estimatesHeat pump cooling quotes focus on temperature drop, but humidity removal is the part that actually decides comfort and running cost.
- Why "heat pumps don't work in the cold" is the wrong myth to worry aboutHeat pumps do work in the cold. The real myth is believing minimum operating temperature is the number that matters for your install.
- Vetting a refrigerant handling licence before heat pump work startsBefore a heat pump installer touches refrigerant lines, check their handling licence. Here's what the card actually proves and what it doesn't.
- Why a return-on-investment number for a heat pump rarely survives real lifeMost heat pump payback calculations use one winter's gas price and a brochure COP. Here's why the real payback period almost never matches the quote.
- Vetting a ducted heat pump installer: the warranty registration trapMost heat pump warranties need the installer to register the system within days. Miss that step and the manufacturer owes you nothing.