Why NatHERS and HERS ratings ignore your actual orientation
I sat in on an assessment last month on a block off Beach Road in a bayside Melbourne suburb, and the thing that stuck with me wasn't the insulation batts or the window schedule. It was the assessor standing in the backyard for a good ten minutes, tapping notes into a tablet, just working out exactly where north actually was relative to the living room glazing. That's the part homeowners never think about, and it's the part that can quietly make or break a star rating.
NatHERS and HERS ratings both lean heavily on orientation. Not as a footnote, but as one of the two or three biggest levers in the whole model. And yet most homeowners I talk to assume the rating is mostly about insulation R-values and glazing U-values. Those matter, sure. But a house with mediocre insulation facing true north with well-managed eaves can out-perform a heavily insulated house facing west with none, on paper and often in real winter and summer comfort too.
What the software actually does with your compass bearing
NatHERS uses accredited software, commonly AccuRate or FirstRate5, which runs an hourly thermal simulation across a full reference year of climate data for your specific zone. Orientation isn't a rough tick-box in that model, it's a specific number, usually captured to within a few degrees off true north, not magnetic north. That distinction genuinely trips people up. Magnetic declination in parts of Australia can be ten degrees or more off true north, and if an assessor uses a phone compass without correcting for it, the whole simulation shifts.
In the US, HERS assessors working under the RESNET standard capture orientation as part of the building geometry input for RemRate or Ekotrope, and the same physics applies even though the compliance pathway and index scoring differ. My colleague wrote a good breakdown of how the two systems compare if you want the mechanics side by side, see NatHERS vs. HERS: How Australian and US Home Energy Ratings Compare.
The reason this matters so much is that orientation determines solar heat gain through glazing, and glazing is usually the leakiest part of any home's thermal envelope by a wide margin, more than walls, more than roof, once you account for area-adjusted heat flow. A north-facing window in southern Australia gets low winter sun angle and can be shaded from high summer sun with a modest eave. A west-facing window of the same size gets brutal low-angle summer afternoon sun that no eave design handles well, because the sun is coming in sideways, not from above.
Why the assessor can't just eyeball it from the street
I've watched assessors get this wrong in ways that aren't their fault. Plans supplied by builders sometimes show north incorrectly, or a renovation rotates a home's living areas relative to the original approved plan without anyone updating the compliance drawing. A good assessor cross-checks the stated orientation against satellite imagery and an on-site compass reading before they trust the plan. A rushed one doesn't.
This is one of the on-site checks that genuinely separates a careful assessment from a box-ticking one, alongside the things we've covered before on what assessors are actually meant to inspect, see What a NatHERS or HERS Assessor Actually Checks On-Site. If you're getting a rating done and you want to ask one sharp question, ask whether they've confirmed true north against the site, not just accepted the architectural plan's north arrow.
Shading from neighbouring structures is the other half of this problem, and it's the half that's almost impossible to capture accurately without a site visit. A two-storey house going up next door, a mature tree on the boundary, even a carport roofline, all change the effective solar access to your windows regardless of what the compass says. NatHERS modelling does account for permanent shading if it's captured correctly at assessment time, but a rating done before a neighbour's second storey exists won't reflect the shade that arrives two years later. Nobody re-rates a house because next door built up.
The gap between a paper rating and how the room actually feels
Here's where I'll push back a little on how these ratings get talked about at open homes and in marketing material. A 7-star NatHERS certificate tells you the whole-of-house average annual heating and cooling load is low under the modelled reference climate. It does not tell you that the west-facing main bedroom won't cook in late afternoon in February, because the model can average a poorly-oriented room's excess load against a well-oriented room's surplus efficiency elsewhere in the house. We've written specifically about this averaging effect and the comfort mismatch it causes, worth reading if you've ever wondered how a high-star home can still feel wrong in one particular room, see Can you get a 7-star NatHERS rating and still freeze in July?. Orientation is usually the biggest single driver of that room-by-room mismatch. A rating is a whole-house energy metric, not a room comfort guarantee, and I reckon that distinction should be printed on every certificate in bold, not buried in the assessor's software output.
The practical upshot for anyone buying or renovating: ask to see the orientation data, not just the star number. A good assessor or building designer can show you a solar access diagram for each major glazed elevation. If most of your glazing faces west or east with no external shading and the rating still came out high, dig into why, because it usually means gains are being offset by something else in the model, like a small footprint or heavy insulation elsewhere, and that offset doesn't help the west bedroom in summer.
What you can actually control after the fact
You can't rotate a house. But orientation problems have real, non-trivial fixes once you know where the exposure actually sits. External shading devices, retrofit eaves, external blinds or well-chosen deciduous planting on a west elevation do more for comfort than another layer of ceiling insulation in most retrofit budgets I've seen priced. Glazing choice matters here too, and if you're weighing up whether the extra pane of a triple-glazed unit is worth it on a problem elevation specifically, we've covered the trade-off in detail, see Double vs Triple Glazing: When the Extra Pane Is Actually Worth It. Low-e coatings with the right solar heat gain coefficient for your specific elevation, not a blanket spec across the whole house, is often the smarter spend. West glass wants a low SHGC coating; north glass in a cold climate can often afford a higher one to capture useful winter gain.
Air sealing doesn't fix orientation problems directly, but it changes how much the orientation problem actually costs you in running expenses, because a leaky envelope lets that unwanted heat gain (or loss) move through the house faster in both directions. If you haven't sorted sealing before adding insulation, that sequencing genuinely changes outcomes, and we've laid out why the order matters in Air Sealing Before Insulation: The Order of Operations That Actually Saves Energy.
A quick check before you commission a rating
If you're building new and haven't locked in floor plan orientation on the block yet, this is the single cheapest moment to fix an orientation problem, because it costs nothing to rotate a design on paper compared to retrofitting shading after the slab is poured. Talk to your designer about which elevation the main living glazing should face before you fall in love with a facade rendering that happens to look best from the street. I've seen good architects on projects around Ocean Grove get this right by putting the display-facing facade on the south or east side and pushing the big glass to where the sun access actually works, rather than where the street presentation looks best. It's a small adjustment on paper and a genuinely large one over twenty years of heating and cooling bills.
For US readers, the RESNET HERS Index methodology documentation from the Residential Energy Services Network covers the same orientation input requirements under a different scoring scale, and it's worth a skim if you want the technical detail behind the index number on your own HERS certificate. The ENERGY STAR program's home certification pages also reference HERS index thresholds if you're trying to work out what your number actually buys you in efficiency terms.
None of this means the rating system is broken. It means the number on the certificate is an average, built on assumptions about your compass bearing and your neighbour's silhouette, and averages hide detail by design. Ask about orientation specifically next time you're getting a rating done, or reviewing one on a house you're about to buy. It's a five-minute question that tells you more about which rooms will actually be comfortable than the star number ever will on its own.
Common questions
- Does NatHERS use true north or magnetic north for orientation?
- True north. Magnetic declination varies by location and can be off by ten degrees or more in parts of Australia, so an assessor relying on an uncorrected compass reading can introduce a real error into the simulation.
- Can a house get a high star rating even if the main living area faces badly?
- Yes. Both NatHERS and HERS produce a whole-house average metric, so strong performance in one room or elevation can offset poor performance in another, even though the poorly oriented room will still feel uncomfortable in practice.
- Will a rating account for a new building next door that creates shade?
- Only if that shading existed at the time of assessment and was captured in the model. A rating done before a neighbouring structure was built won't reflect shade that arrives later, and homes generally aren't re-rated automatically when that happens.
- Is it worth changing house orientation on a new build to improve the rating?
- It's usually the cheapest and most effective single change you can make before construction starts, since it costs nothing on paper compared to retrofitting shading, glazing upgrades or insulation later to compensate for poor solar access.
Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.
Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).
More from Ben Sorensen
- Why a NatHERS or HERS rating can change without touching the buildA NatHERS or HERS rating can shift star bands when software updates, climate files get revised, or rules change — even if your house hasn't.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating ignores your floor coveringsCarpet, tile and polished concrete all score the same in a NatHERS or HERS model, even though they feel wildly different underfoot and change how your heating actually performs.
- Vetting an insulation installer: the R-value receipt nobody asks forInsulation installers rarely need a specific trade licence, which is exactly why the paperwork trail matters more than the handshake.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never touches your thermal bridgesA NatHERS or HERS rating models your walls as flat layers, which means steel studs, balcony slabs and window reveals rarely get the credit (or blame) they deserve.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never checks your orientation on siteYour NatHERS or HERS star rating locks in orientation at design stage, but nobody re-checks it once the slab is poured the wrong way round.
- Vetting a window glazier for new-build glazing: what to checkBefore a glazier touches your new-build windows, check the licence, the AS 2047 compliance paperwork and the install method. Here's what actually matters.