Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never mentions your ductwork

By Ben Sorensen · September 27, 2026 · 7 min read
Modern energy-efficient house exterior
Photo by Naksha Banwao on Unsplash

I was on site in Bacchus Marsh a few months back, watching a ducted system get roughed in through a roof space on a house that had come in at 7.2 stars. Lovely rating. Genuinely well-detailed envelope — the assessor had clearly earned the number. But the duct run from the unit to the far bedroom was about nine metres of flex duct, three bends, sitting directly on top of R3.5 ceiling batts with a gap you could post a letter through at one joint. None of that shows up on the certificate. None of it changes the star rating. And it will absolutely change what that homeowner pays to run the thing.

This is the part of a NatHERS rating or a US HERS rating that catches people out, because both systems spend enormous energy modelling the building envelope — wall construction, glazing performance, roof insulation, orientation, shading — and then treat the mechanical distribution system as almost an afterthought. The software assumes a delivery system. It doesn't verify one exists in good condition.

What the rating tools actually model

NatHERS software (AccuRate or FirstRate5, depending on which the assessor is licensed for) calculates the heating and cooling load of the conditioned space based on the fabric — walls, roof, floor, windows, and their thermal performance. It spits out an energy figure in megajoules per square metre, which converts to the familiar star rating. Nowhere in that calculation does it ask what brand of ducted system will heat the house, how long the duct runs are, or whether they're insulated to a sensible R-value.

The US equivalent, the HERS Index administered under RESNET's standards, is actually a step ahead here in one respect: a proper HERS rating includes a duct blower door test as part of the diagnostic testing package, alongside the whole-house blower door test for air leakage. That's a real, measured number — CFM25 of duct leakage, tested with the system pressurised. Good HERS raters catch bad ductwork because the protocol makes them test it.

NatHERS has no equivalent mandatory step. The star rating is a design-stage prediction, not a commissioning test — a distinction I've written about before when covering why a NatHERS rating is a design tool, not a build receipt. Ductwork sits squarely in that blind spot. It gets designed after the energy assessment, installed by a different trade to a different set of priorities, and never checked against the assumptions baked into the star rating.

Where the losses actually happen

Duct losses come from three places, and they compound. First, conductive loss through the duct wall itself when it runs through an unconditioned space — a roof cavity in summer in Melbourne can sit well above 50°C, and a poorly insulated supply duct carrying 14°C conditioned air through that space is losing capacity before the air even reaches the room.

Second, leakage at joints and connections. Flex duct clamped with a single zip tie, plenum connections that were never properly sealed, boots that don't seat flush to the ceiling — all of it bleeds conditioned air into the roof space instead of the room it was meant to reach. US Department of Energy figures commonly cited in residential retrofit programmes put typical duct leakage in unsealed systems at somewhere around 20-30% of total airflow, which is a genuinely large number when you consider that's air the heat pump or furnace already spent energy conditioning.

Third, and this one's underrated: static pressure losses from too many bends, undersized duct diameter, or runs that are simply too long for the fan curve of the unit. This doesn't just waste energy, it changes how the whole system performs — related to the mismatch I've covered in the zoning mistake that makes multi-head heat pumps run backwards, where airflow problems downstream of the unit undo good equipment selection upstream.

Why this doesn't show up on the certificate

Partly it's scope. NatHERS assessors are engaged to model the building envelope for planning permit purposes, generally before a mechanical contractor has even been selected. They physically cannot model ductwork that doesn't exist yet in any documented form. The on-site checks a NatHERS or HERS assessor actually performs focus on what's visible and fixed — insulation batts, window specifications, wall construction — not the ducted system that gets fitted weeks or months later by a separate trade.

Partly it's a genuine gap in the regulatory framework. Under the National Construction Code, the energy efficiency provisions that feed into a NatHERS assessment are largely fabric-focused; ductwork sealing and insulation requirements exist in AS 4254 for ductwork and in various mechanical services standards, but compliance with those sits with the mechanical contractor and building surveyor, not the energy rater. Two separate compliance pathways, two separate trades, and nobody whose job is to check the seam between them.

In my view this is a structural weakness in how Australia does residential energy assessment, and it's one area where the US programme, whatever its own quirks, has actually got the discipline right by making the duct test mandatory rather than optional.

What actually shows up when someone checks

I've seen post-occupancy blower-door-and-duct-test combinations on new-build ducted systems turn up leakage rates that would fail outright under a RESNET protocol, sitting quietly inside houses that scored well above six stars on their NatHERS certificate. The star rating told the buyer the envelope was good. It told them nothing about whether 20% of their conditioned air was dumping into the roof space before Christmas.

The fix isn't complicated, it's just rarely specified. Duct insulation should match or exceed the ceiling insulation R-value in that zone — running an R1.0 flex duct through an R5.0 roof space insulation zone is a false economy nobody notices until the bill arrives. Joints should be mechanically fastened and mastic-sealed, not just taped. Runs should be as short and as straight as the floor plan allows, which is a design decision that has to happen before the ducted system is drawn up, not after.

If you're commissioning a ducted heat pump, it's worth asking the installer directly whether they test and seal duct joints as standard practice, and whether they'll provide any documentation of that. It's the same instinct that should drive you to check the commissioning paperwork most installers skip — a system that isn't tested is a system nobody's actually verified.

What to ask before the ducted system goes in

If you're at design stage and a ducted system is on the table, this is worth raising with your mechanical contractor before the layout is finalised, not after. Ask where the plant and main trunk will sit relative to conditioned space — a unit and main duct run inside the thermal envelope loses far less than one buried in an unconditioned roof space. Ask about insulation R-value on the ductwork itself, and whether joints get mastic-sealed as standard or only on request. None of this is exotic; it's standard trade practice that sometimes gets value-engineered out when a quote needs trimming.

It's also worth remembering that duct performance interacts with load calculations. An undersized or leaky duct system can make a correctly sized heat pump behave like an oversized one that short-cycles and struggles with comfort — the unit compensates for lost capacity by running harder, which isn't the same as running efficiently. If your load calculation was done properly but the ductwork wasn't, you can still end up with a house that's technically over-conditioned and unevenly comfortable at the same time.

Where this leaves the star rating

None of this means the NatHERS or HERS rating is wrong, or that it's not worth having. It measures what it was designed to measure, which is the building fabric's thermal performance under a standardised climate file — a topic I've gone into more in what a rating actually assumes about your climate file. It's just not a mechanical services audit, and treating it as one is where people get burned.

The honest read is that a high star rating buys you a good envelope, and a good envelope makes every downstream system's job easier. But it doesn't guarantee the downstream systems were installed to match that quality. If your heat pump or ducted system is the last thing installed in an otherwise well-rated build, it's worth spending the extra half-day on commissioning checks rather than assuming the star rating already covered it. It didn't.

Tagged

Common questions

Does a NatHERS rating include any check of ductwork at all?
No. NatHERS models the building envelope — walls, roof, glazing, floor — based on standardised occupancy and climate assumptions. Ductwork design generally happens after the assessment and isn't part of the star rating calculation.
Does a US HERS rating test ductwork?
Yes, typically. A proper HERS rating under RESNET's protocol includes a duct blower door test measuring leakage in CFM25, alongside the whole-house air leakage test. It's one of the more meaningful differences between the two systems.
How much energy can leaky ductwork actually waste?
Figures commonly cited in US residential retrofit programmes put typical unsealed duct leakage at around 20-30% of total system airflow — conditioned air that never reaches the room it was meant for.
What should I ask a ducted heat pump installer about ductwork?
Ask about duct insulation R-value relative to the ceiling zone it passes through, whether joints are mastic-sealed as standard, and whether they can provide any test documentation or commissioning records for the completed install.
About the author
BS
Ben Sorensen
Green building · Perth, AU

Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.

Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).

More from Ben Sorensen