Why a NatHERS or HERS rating won't tell you what to fix first
I sat with a client in Bellarine last month who'd just paid for a NatHERS assessment on a 1990s brick veneer she was about to renovate. Six stars. She looked at the number, looked at me, and said "so what do I actually do with this?" Fair question. The rating itself is close to useless for planning renovation work. It's the paperwork behind it that matters, and almost nobody asks to see it.
This is the gap I keep running into with homeowners and even some renovators. They treat the star rating as a diagnosis, when it's actually more like a final exam score. It tells you whether the house passed, not which subject it failed. If you're planning to spend money on insulation, glazing or draught sealing, the rating number alone will send you in the wrong direction more often than not.
The star rating is an output, not a diagnosis
NatHERS in Australia and HERS in the US both work the same way underneath: an assessor builds a thermal model of the house, the software runs it against a reference climate file for that specific location, and it spits out an estimate of the heating and cooling energy the house will need across a year. That number gets converted to a star rating (or a HERS index score in the US system). The conversion is the part everyone sees. The model behind it is the part that's actually useful.
The star rating on its own can't tell you whether your problem is the ceiling insulation, the west-facing glazing, or air leakage around the old evaporative cooling ducting nobody's used in a decade. A five-star home with excellent insulation but leaky old windows and a four-star home with great glazing but no insulation can land on similar numbers for completely different reasons. Same score, opposite renovation priorities.
I've written before about why your NatHERS star rating can change without touching the house — climate file updates, software version changes, even a different assessor measuring the same house can shift the number. That volatility is another reason to stop treating the star figure as gospel and start treating it as one output among several worth reading properly.
What's actually sitting in the assessor's file
Every NatHERS assessment produces a Certificate, but it also produces a much longer set of underlying inputs that most homeowners never ask to see: the zone-by-zone breakdown, the construction assumptions for each wall and roof section, glazing specifications by orientation, and — critically — the separate heating load and cooling load figures rather than just the combined star number.
Ask your assessor for the full software output, not just the one-page certificate. In Australia this usually means requesting the assessor's report from the NatHERS-accredited software (AccuRate, BERS Pro or FirstRate5 are the common ones), which breaks down predicted energy use room by room. In the US, a HERS rater working under RESNET standards produces a similarly detailed report, and by law you're entitled to a copy of what was actually modelled, not just the index number on the label.
This breakdown is where the useful information lives. If the cooling load is disproportionately high relative to heating, that's pointing at solar gain through glass, poor shading, or dark roofing, not insulation. If heating load dominates and cooling is modest, you're more likely looking at envelope leakage or under-insulated ceiling and subfloor. The star rating averages these two numbers together and throws away the signal in the process.
Reading the room-by-room breakdown properly
Most software outputs a load estimate per thermal zone, roughly per room or room group. I always ask clients to look at which room is carrying the worst numbers before touching anything else. In my experience it's very often a west-facing bedroom or living area with underperforming glazing, or a room over an unheated garage with no subfloor insulation at all.
A few patterns show up again and again in these breakdowns:
Rooms with large west or north-west glazing (in the southern hemisphere) frequently carry cooling loads two to three times higher than similarly sized east-facing rooms, even with identical glass. That's orientation and shading, not glass quality, and no amount of ceiling insulation fixes it. If you're weighing up whether an upgrade is worth it here, our piece on double vs triple glazing and when the extra pane is actually worth it goes into where the payback genuinely stacks up versus where it doesn't.
Rooms directly under an accessible, poorly insulated roof space often show heating loads well out of proportion to the rest of the house, particularly in older builds where ceiling batts have slumped or been disturbed by trades running cables. This is a five-minute manhole inspection, not a mystery, but the star certificate alone won't flag it as the priority.
Extensions built to a different era's code than the original house frequently show up as the worst-performing zone in the model, because they were built to whatever the minimum was at the time, sometimes decades before or after the main structure.
Where air leakage hides in the numbers
Here's a limitation worth being upfront about: NatHERS modelling in Australia has historically used a default air infiltration assumption rather than a measured blower door result for most standard assessments, unless you specifically commission one alongside it. That means the software might be crediting your house with tighter construction than it actually has, or penalising a genuinely well-sealed house that never gets the recognition.
If the room-by-room breakdown shows a heating load that seems high relative to the stated insulation levels, air leakage is the first thing I'd suspect, and it's exactly the kind of gap a documented rating won't catch on its own. This is where a proper blower door test earns its keep, and it's worth reading the order-of-operations piece on air sealing before insulation before you spend money on batts that leakage will undermine anyway. If you're hiring someone to run that test, our guide to vetting a blower door contractor covers the licensing and red flags worth checking.
The US RESNET protocol actually mandates a blower door test as part of a standard HERS rating, which is one of the genuine structural differences between the two systems worth understanding if you're comparing notes with someone overseas — I covered that comparison in more depth in NatHERS vs HERS: how Australian and US home energy ratings compare. In my view this is a real weakness in the standard Australian assessment path, and I'd like to see measured infiltration data become mandatory rather than optional, because right now two houses with identical star ratings can have genuinely different leakage rates hiding behind the same number.
What to actually ask your assessor for
Before you commission a rating, or after you've already got one filed away from a previous purchase, ask for these specifically rather than accepting the one-page summary:
The full software report showing zone-by-zone heating and cooling loads, not just the combined annual figure. The glazing schedule with U-values and Solar Heat Gain Coefficients (SHGC) listed by orientation, so you can see which windows are actually doing the damage. The insulation R-values assumed for each element of the building, roof, walls and subfloor separately, so you can check them against what's actually installed rather than what was on the plans. And whether infiltration was modelled as a default assumption or measured on-site, because that single detail changes how much weight you should put on the heating number.
None of this is exotic information. Assessors already have it sitting in the software file they used to generate your certificate. Most homeowners just never ask, because the certificate looks like the finished product. It isn't. It's the summary slide at the end of a report that has all the actually useful content in the appendix nobody hands over unless you request it. For a broader refresher on what an assessor physically checks on-site before any of this modelling happens, see what a NatHERS or HERS assessor actually checks on-site.
Turning the data into a renovation order
Once you've got the room-by-room numbers, the priority order mostly writes itself. Fix the worst-performing zone first, not the easiest one. I see plenty of renovations start with new insulation in a spare room because it's cheap and straightforward, while the actual problem room, usually the main bedroom over an unheated garage, sits untouched for another five years because nobody looked at the breakdown.
The Clean Energy Council's guidance on home energy efficiency and the US Department of Energy's home energy audit resources both push the same underlying point: whole-house averages are for comparing houses to each other, not for deciding what to fix in yours. Use the zone data for that.
If you're planning glazing work off the back of this, ask the installer to quote against the specific under-performing rooms rather than the whole house uniformly. And if insulation is the fix, our piece on questions to ask an insulation or green-building contractor before you sign has the specifics worth confirming before anyone starts.
My client in Bellarine ended up spending most of her renovation budget on the west bedroom's glazing and a subfloor insulation top-up, not the ceiling batts she'd originally budgeted for. Same star rating on the certificate either way, but a genuinely different house to live in come February. That's the difference between reading the label and reading the file underneath it.
Common questions
- Can I get the detailed software report if I only received a one-page NatHERS certificate?
- Yes. The certificate is a summary of a much larger file the assessor generated in the accredited software. You're entitled to ask for the full assessor's report, including the zone-by-zone breakdown, and a reasonable assessor should provide it without much fuss.
- Does a higher star rating always mean lower energy bills?
- Generally yes for heating and cooling, but the star rating doesn't capture hot water, appliances, lighting or plug loads, so two homes with the same rating can still have quite different total energy bills depending on what's plugged in and running.
- Is a blower door test worth paying for separately if my NatHERS assessment didn't include one?
- If the room-by-room breakdown shows unexplained heating loads relative to stated insulation levels, yes. It's the only way to confirm whether air leakage, rather than insulation quality, is the actual driver of the number.
- Why do two houses with identical star ratings sometimes feel completely different to live in?
- Because the star rating averages heating and cooling loads across the whole year and the whole house. A home that's freezing in winter but mild in summer can land on the same combined score as one that's comfortable in winter but stifling in summer.
Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.
Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).
More from Ben Sorensen
- Why a NatHERS or HERS rating can change without touching the buildA NatHERS or HERS rating can shift star bands when software updates, climate files get revised, or rules change — even if your house hasn't.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating ignores your floor coveringsCarpet, tile and polished concrete all score the same in a NatHERS or HERS model, even though they feel wildly different underfoot and change how your heating actually performs.
- Vetting an insulation installer: the R-value receipt nobody asks forInsulation installers rarely need a specific trade licence, which is exactly why the paperwork trail matters more than the handshake.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never touches your thermal bridgesA NatHERS or HERS rating models your walls as flat layers, which means steel studs, balcony slabs and window reveals rarely get the credit (or blame) they deserve.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never checks your orientation on siteYour NatHERS or HERS star rating locks in orientation at design stage, but nobody re-checks it once the slab is poured the wrong way round.
- Vetting a window glazier for new-build glazing: what to checkBefore a glazier touches your new-build windows, check the licence, the AS 2047 compliance paperwork and the install method. Here's what actually matters.