Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never asks about your hot water
I had a client in the Dandenong Ranges last month holding a 7.2-star NatHERS certificate like it was a guarantee. Lovely house, double-glazed, good bulk insulation in the roof. Her gas storage hot water system was twenty years old, corroding at the base, and running most nights because the tank had lost half its recovery capacity. None of that showed up anywhere on her certificate. It never will. That's not a flaw in the rating, it's just not what the rating is for, and most homeowners never get told the difference.
A home energy rating like NatHERS in Australia or HERS in the US scores the building envelope. Walls, roof, floor, windows, glazing, orientation, insulation levels, air leakage assumptions. It's a thermal performance score for the shell you live inside. What it deliberately excludes is almost everything that actually burns the energy: hot water, cooking, lighting, pool pumps, and the plug-in appliances that run every single day whether the house is well insulated or not.
What the rating actually models
NatHERS uses accredited software (AccuRate or FirstRate5 are the common ones) to simulate how much energy a notional heating and cooling system would need to keep the house within a comfortable temperature band, given the climate file for your postcode, the house's geometry, its glazing specification and its insulation values. It's a space conditioning load estimate, full stop. The US HERS Index, run through RESNET-accredited raters, is broader in scope — it does roll in some mechanical equipment and duct performance — but it still treats the building envelope as the backbone of the score and doesn't audit your actual appliance fleet the way a full home energy audit would.
I've written before about why a NatHERS or HERS rating doesn't care about your energy bill, and the hot water gap is really the same story from a different angle. The rating isn't modelling your household. It's modelling a reference house with reference occupants doing reference things, inside your shell, in your climate zone. Nobody in that reference house showers for eleven minutes. Nobody runs a spa bath twice a week. Nobody has four teenagers doing five loads of washing on hot wash because somebody's hockey kit smells.
Why hot water and appliances were left out
This isn't an oversight, it's a scope decision made for a reasonable engineering reason. Hot water consumption varies wildly by household size, behaviour, system type and fuel source, and none of that is fixed at design time the way a window's U-value is. A rating has to be reproducible. Two assessors modelling the same house with the same inputs should land close to the same star result — that's the entire point of having an accredited software tool and a standard methodology. The moment you fold in hot water, you're folding in assumptions about household size, showering habits and system efficiency that nobody can standardise with any integrity.
Separately, in both the Australian and US systems, there are other instruments that do cover the plant and equipment side. In Australia that's state-based minimum equipment standards and, increasingly, state energy efficiency schemes; in the US it's ENERGY STAR equipment ratings and the Uniform Energy Factor labelling the ENERGY STAR programme maintains for water heaters. The envelope rating and the equipment rating are meant to work as a pair. The problem is almost nobody reads them as a pair, because only one of them shows up on the certificate stapled to the sale contract.
What that means for the house you're buying or renting
I've looked at enough energy certificates to know that a strong star rating gets treated as a blanket reassurance, and it shouldn't be. A 7-star house with an ancient electric resistance hot water tank, inefficient downlights throughout, and a 15-year-old fridge in the garage can still carry a higher running cost than a 6-star house with a heat pump hot water system and sensible appliances. The star rating tells you the shell is doing its job. It tells you nothing about the box in the laundry heating your water, or whether that box is a resistive element running at close to 1-to-1 efficiency or a heat pump system running at a coefficient of performance well above that.
I'd go further and say this is one of the more structurally odd parts of the rating system — the certificate gets the prominent placement in a property listing, while the hot water system, which in many Australian households is the single largest energy load in the home, isn't disclosed anywhere near as visibly. Anecdotally I reckon more homeowners could save more money switching an old electric or gas storage unit to a heat pump water heater than they'd save chasing another half-star on their envelope rating. Both matter, but they're not remotely equivalent in dollar terms for most existing homes.
Where this actually bites on an existing home
New builds get the rating baked in at design stage, so the envelope numbers are reasonably locked in before anyone moves furniture in. Existing homes are a different problem entirely. If you're buying a resale property, the NatHERS certificate (where one exists — it's often absent on older housing stock) tells you nothing about the actual hot water unit sitting in the roof space or side yard, its age, its fuel type, or its remaining service life. You have to go and look at it yourself, check the data plate, note the manufacture date, and factor a likely replacement into your budget.
This is exactly the kind of gap a proper home energy audit closes. A blower door and thermal imaging assessment picks up air leakage the star rating software only estimates on paper, and a competent auditor will also walk you through the hot water system, the appliance fleet and the lighting, which the envelope rating was never built to cover. If you're serious about understanding total household energy cost rather than just shell performance, that's the inspection to commission, not a re-run of the NatHERS assessment.
What to actually check yourself
On a walkthrough, I always tell people to find the data plate on the hot water unit and note three things: fuel type, tank size if it's storage, and manufacture date. A gas or electric storage unit much past twelve to fifteen years is a reasonable candidate for replacement regardless of condition, simply because recovery efficiency degrades and corrosion risk climbs. If you're planning an upgrade, a heat pump hot water system is worth comparing against straight electric resistance or gas storage on running cost, not just purchase price — the efficiency gap is large enough that it usually changes the calculation within a handful of years.
If you're in Australia and weighing that upgrade, it's worth checking the Solar Victoria Hot Water Rebate or the NSW Hot Water Upgrade Incentive if you're in those states, rather than assuming a figure from an old brochure. In the US, the US Department of Energy's Home Energy Rebates programmes and state-level schemes like NYSERDA's equipment programmes are the right place to check current eligibility rather than guessing. I'd steer well clear of taking a rebate figure from a sales rep at face value; check the source programme page directly.
For product comparison, models like the Voltex MAX hybrid heat pump water heater or the ProTerra Hot Water Heat Pump give a sense of what a heat pump system offers over resistive storage, though the right size and configuration depends on your household's actual hot water draw, which again, nobody's rating certificate has measured.
Reading the certificate for what it is
None of this is an argument against the rating system. It does a genuinely useful job within its scope, and I'd rather have a standardised, reproducible envelope score than none at all. The mistake is reading a single number as a verdict on the whole house's running cost. It isn't designed to be that, and treating it that way sets homeowners up to under-budget for the mechanical and plumbing side of their energy bill.
Next time you're handed a certificate with a shiny star number on it, ask the obvious follow-up question nobody asks at settlement: what's actually heating the water, and how old is it? That single question will tell you more about your likely first-year energy cost than another half-star on the envelope ever will.
Common questions
- Does a NatHERS or HERS rating include hot water at all?
- NatHERS doesn't model your actual hot water system or usage; it scores the building envelope's thermal performance only. The US HERS Index is broader and factors in some mechanical equipment and duct performance, but neither system audits your specific hot water unit's age, condition or efficiency the way a home energy audit would.
- Can a high star rating still mean high energy bills?
- Yes. A strong envelope rating lowers the heating and cooling load, but hot water, lighting, cooking and plug-in appliances aren't part of that score. An old, inefficient hot water system in an otherwise well-rated house can still drive a high energy bill.
- How do I find out if a house's hot water system is efficient?
- Check the data plate on the unit for fuel type, tank size and manufacture date, and compare its likely running cost against a heat pump hot water system. A home energy auditor can assess this alongside envelope performance if you want a fuller picture.
- Is it worth replacing hot water systems before chasing a better NatHERS score?
- For most existing homes, replacing an old storage hot water unit with a heat pump system tends to deliver bigger running-cost savings than incremental envelope upgrades aimed at a higher star rating, though both are worth doing where the budget allows.
Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.
Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).
More from Ben Sorensen
- Why a NatHERS or HERS rating can change without touching the buildA NatHERS or HERS rating can shift star bands when software updates, climate files get revised, or rules change — even if your house hasn't.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating ignores your floor coveringsCarpet, tile and polished concrete all score the same in a NatHERS or HERS model, even though they feel wildly different underfoot and change how your heating actually performs.
- Vetting an insulation installer: the R-value receipt nobody asks forInsulation installers rarely need a specific trade licence, which is exactly why the paperwork trail matters more than the handshake.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never touches your thermal bridgesA NatHERS or HERS rating models your walls as flat layers, which means steel studs, balcony slabs and window reveals rarely get the credit (or blame) they deserve.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never checks your orientation on siteYour NatHERS or HERS star rating locks in orientation at design stage, but nobody re-checks it once the slab is poured the wrong way round.
- Vetting a window glazier for new-build glazing: what to checkBefore a glazier touches your new-build windows, check the licence, the AS 2047 compliance paperwork and the install method. Here's what actually matters.