Why your NatHERS or HERS rating doesn't care about your energy bill

By Ben Sorensen · October 15, 2026 · 7 min read
Modern energy-efficient home exterior
Photo by Naksha Banwao on Unsplash

I had a client in Geelong last year hold up a NatHERS certificate and ask me, flat out, "so what's this going to save me a year?" The honest answer is the certificate can't tell him. It was never built to. That confuses almost everyone who's handed one at settlement, because the star rating on the front page looks exactly like the kind of number that should translate into dollars. It doesn't, and understanding why changes how you should actually use the thing.

NatHERS in Australia and HERS in the US are both envelope models. They simulate the thermal performance of the fabric around your rooms — walls, roof, floor, glazing, orientation, shading — against a reference climate file and a standardised pattern of heating and cooling. What comes out the other end is an estimate of the energy load your house would need to stay within a comfort band, expressed in megajoules per square metre per year, then converted into a star rating out of ten. It is a proxy for thermal performance, not a forecast of your power bill.

Why the methodology stops at the wall, not the meter

The assessors I've worked alongside — and I've sat in on plenty of onsite inspections over the years, including a half-day with an accredited assessor in Ballarat checking insulation batts in a new double-storey build — are measuring physical things: R-values of installed materials, glazing specifications, floor area, window-to-wall ratios, shading devices, orientation relative to true north. Everything that feeds the rating is a property of the building shell. What happens after that, how many appliances you run, what tariff you're on, whether you've got a heat pump or a dinosaur of a ducted gas system, is deliberately excluded from the star number.

That's not an oversight. It's the whole point of a standardised method. If NatHERS tried to account for appliance efficiency and occupant behaviour in the star rating itself, two identical houses with different owners would get different ratings for the same shell, and the rating would become useless as a design and compliance tool. The NatHERS administrator's technical documentation is explicit that the software models a standardised occupancy pattern specifically so the shell performance is isolated from how any particular household actually lives. In the US, the RESNET HERS Index works the same way in principle: it's a relative energy-use index for the home's design, not a utility bill predictor, benchmarked against a reference home of identical geometry.

The gap between megajoules and dollars

Here's where it gets genuinely misleading if nobody explains it. The star rating converts a thermal load (heating and cooling demand) into a number. It does not know what equipment will meet that load, so it cannot know the running cost. A 7-star home heated with a high-COP heat pump and a 7-star home heated with a bar radiator will have wildly different bills despite an identical star rating, because the rating stopped at "how much energy does the shell need," not "how efficiently is that energy delivered."

I'd argue this is the single most commonly misunderstood part of the whole system, more so even than the orientation assumptions or the climate file quirks I've covered elsewhere. People treat the star rating like a fuel-economy label on a car, assuming it bakes in cost. It doesn't bake in cost because it doesn't know your appliances, your tariff structure, your household size, or whether you leave the heater running while you're at work. Our piece on what a NatHERS or HERS rating assumes about how you'll live in the house goes into the standardised occupancy pattern in more detail, and it's worth reading alongside this one because the two gaps compound each other.

What actually determines your bill

If the star rating isn't the bill predictor, what is? Three things, roughly in order of impact for most households I've looked at: the efficiency of your heating and cooling equipment, your hot water system, and your actual usage pattern. A well-rated shell with a poorly sized or ageing heat pump can still produce a disappointing bill, which is why I keep pointing people toward the COP number on the box isn't the COP you'll actually get before they assume a high star rating has done all the work for them.

Hot water is often the quiet one. A standard electric resistance tank in an otherwise excellent 7-star house can chew through more energy than the heating and cooling combined, and the rating certificate won't flag it because domestic hot water load is handled separately from the envelope calculation (and in many jurisdictions isn't part of the star number at all). Swapping to something like a heat pump hot water unit, similar in principle to the ProTerra Hot Water Heat Pump or the Voltex MAX hybrid heat pump water heater, moves the needle on the bill far more than most people expect from a line item the rating barely touches.

Why two identical-star houses can have very different bills

I've seen this play out literally next door to each other, two near-identical townhouses on the same short street off Separation Street in a Melbourne infill development, same builder, same plans, both rated 7 stars. One owner installed a ducted heat pump with reasonable zoning; the other kept electric panel heaters "for now" and never got around to switching. Same star certificate, genuinely different winter bills, and the certificate predicted neither outcome because it was never asked to.

This is also why I'm cautious when a real estate listing leans hard on the star rating as a selling point without mentioning what's actually installed. A 7-star shell married to an oversized, badly commissioned system is not the same proposition as a 7-star shell with a correctly sized, well-zoned one — our article on why oversizing a heat pump quietly ruins comfort and running costs covers how badly a mismatched system can undercut good envelope work.

What you can actually do with the certificate

The certificate is still useful, just not as a bill calculator. Use it to compare the relative thermal performance of different design options at the build or renovation stage, that's genuinely what it's built for. Use it to sanity-check that a renovation or extension hasn't quietly dragged performance backwards, since the rating can shift without anyone touching the insulation, something I went through properly in why your NatHERS star rating can change without touching the house. And use it as one input, not the only input, when comparing properties.

For an actual dollar estimate, you need the equipment specs layered on top: heating and cooling system efficiency and sizing, hot water system type, and a realistic read of household occupancy and usage, not the standardised pattern the software assumes. If you're trying to estimate running costs on a heat pump specifically, our heat pump vs gas running costs comparison walks through that math properly, and it's a far more direct route to a dollar figure than squinting at a star rating certificate.

Where this leaves buyers and renovators

None of this means the rating is pointless, whatever my Geelong client thought in the moment. It means you need to stop asking the certificate a question it was never designed to answer. Think of it as a proxy for how hard your heating and cooling system will have to work, not a receipt for what you'll pay. The shell sets the floor on effort; the equipment and your habits set the bill.

If you're assessing a property with a certificate in hand, I'd spend more time asking what's actually installed to meet that envelope load than admiring the star count itself. A assessor measuring R-values and glazing specs under the NatHERS or RESNET frameworks has done their job properly even if the number on the certificate tells you nothing about next July's power bill. That part's still on you to work out, equipment first.

Tagged

Common questions

Does a higher NatHERS or HERS star rating guarantee a lower energy bill?
Not directly. A higher rating means the building shell needs less energy to stay comfortable, but your actual bill depends on the efficiency of your heating, cooling and hot water equipment and how the household uses them, none of which the star rating accounts for.
Why doesn't NatHERS or HERS include appliance efficiency in the star number?
The rating is deliberately standardised to isolate the thermal performance of the building fabric from occupant behaviour and equipment choice, so two different households in the same shell get a consistent, comparable number rather than one that shifts with how they live.
Can two houses with the same star rating have very different running costs?
Yes, and it happens often. Identical shells with different heating systems, hot water units or occupancy patterns can produce noticeably different bills despite carrying the same certificate.
What's a better way to estimate my actual running costs than the star rating?
Look at the efficiency and sizing of your installed heating, cooling and hot water equipment, then model realistic usage against your tariff, rather than relying on the envelope-only star number.
About the author
BS
Ben Sorensen
Green building · Perth, AU

Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.

Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).

More from Ben Sorensen