Why your NatHERS or HERS certificate doesn't list a single R-value

By Ben Sorensen · September 21, 2026 · 7 min read
Modern energy-efficient house exterior
Photo by Naksha Banwao on Unsplash

I had a client in Bellarine Street, Geelong, pull out her freshly issued NatHERS certificate last month and ask me, fairly reasonably, "where's the insulation rating?" She'd been told the house was 7.2 stars. She'd been told it had R2.5 wall batts and R6.0 in the ceiling. But the certificate itself, the actual document with the star graphic on it, didn't mention a single R-value anywhere. She thought something had been left off. Nothing had.

This trips up more people than you'd think, and it's a fair question about how a home energy rating actually works. The certificate is not a materials list. It's the output of a simulation, and the inputs that produced it live in a separate file most homeowners never see.

What's actually on the certificate versus what's in the model

A NatHERS certificate (and its US cousin, the HERS index report) is a summary document. It shows the star rating or index number, the estimated heating and cooling loads, sometimes a breakdown by zone, and administrative details like the assessor's accreditation number and the software version used. What it doesn't show is the assembly-level data that produced those numbers.

That data exists, just not on the certificate. In Australia it's sitting in the assessor's software file, a Chenath-engine program like AccuRate or BERS Pro, and it includes every wall, roof and floor construction type, every window's U-value and SHGC, and every insulation layer modelled into each assembly. In the US, the HERS rater's RESNET-accredited software (REM/Rate or Ekotrope, most commonly) holds the equivalent detail feeding into the HERS Index Score. Neither system is designed to hand that working-out to the owner by default. You have to ask for it.

I'd argue this is a genuine design flaw in how both schemes present results to the public. The star rating is useful shorthand for regulators and for comparing houses at a glance, but it strips out exactly the information a homeowner needs if they want to sanity-check what they were told was installed. My colleague covers this same gap from a different angle in our piece on why a rating is a design tool, not a build receipt — the certificate tells you what the house was designed to achieve, not necessarily what a tradie put in the wall.

Why the rating body doesn't require R-values on the output

The honest answer is that R-values alone would be misleading without context. R2.5 batts in a wall with a thermal bridge every 450mm through timber studs behave differently to R2.5 batts in a well-detailed steel-framed wall with a thermal break. A single number on a certificate can't communicate assembly geometry, so both NatHERS and RESNET default to publishing the output (the star rating, the index score) rather than the inputs.

There's also a practical reason. Assessors build these models from a set of architectural drawings and a specification schedule, sometimes before a single stud goes up. The star rating is a compliance artefact tied to a point in the design process, generally lodged with council or the building surveyor as part of the permit pathway. Attaching raw thermal data to that artefact would clutter a document meant for a specific regulatory purpose, not for retrospective verification of construction quality.

That distinction matters more than most people realise. What a NatHERS or HERS assessor actually checks on-site covers this in more detail, but the short version is that the assessment is largely a documentation exercise unless the assessor does a physical site visit, which isn't always mandatory depending on your jurisdiction and pathway.

What document actually holds the R-values you're after

If you want the assembly detail, ask your assessor for the "NatHERS Certificate" plus the "Assessment Summary" or the raw software output file (commonly an .h2k, .ecp or similar extension depending on the tool). Some assessors will also provide a Construction Details Report, which lists every wall, roof, floor and glazing type modelled, along with the R-value or U-value assumed for each. In the US, ask your HERS rater for the underlying REM/Rate or Ekotrope printout, sometimes called the Rating Data Report. It'll list wall cavity insulation, above-grade wall R-value, ceiling insulation, foundation insulation and window specifications individually, alongside the blower door and duct leakage test numbers if those were performed.

Neither document is automatically issued. On most jobs I've been involved with, from small renovations in Ocean Grove up to larger new builds, the client has to specifically request the backup data. Assessors aren't hiding it, they just don't issue it as standard because most of their clients (builders, mostly) never ask.

Why the gap between "modelled" and "installed" matters more than the number itself

Here's the part that actually costs people money down the track. The R-value in the model is an assumption made at design time. Nothing about the rating process guarantees that the ceiling batts installed on site match the ceiling batts specified in the software file. If your builder substitutes a lower-spec product, or the insulation installer compresses batts to fit a tighter cavity than modelled (which measurably drops effective R-value), your star rating stays printed on a certificate that no longer reflects the house. This is exactly the gap covered in vetting an insulation installer's licence — the person doing the physical install often has no visibility into what the energy rating assumed, and there's no automatic feedback loop checking their work against the model.

I've walked enough job sites to say this isn't rare. A batt compressed to 70% of its rated thickness loses a meaningful chunk of its effective R-value, sometimes 15 to 20%, and nobody catches it unless someone does a blower door test or thermal imaging afterwards. If you want that kind of after-the-fact verification, vetting a blower door and thermal imaging auditor is worth reading before you pay for a report, because not every auditor delivers findings you can actually act on.

Reading the numbers that are on there

Even without R-values listed, the certificate does give you something useful: the heating load and cooling load estimates, usually expressed in MJ/m²/year in Australia. These numbers tell you where the model thinks your energy is going. A house with a high cooling load relative to heating load is telling you the glazing, orientation or shading assumptions are driving summer performance, not insulation levels. This is a genuinely useful diagnostic if you're deciding where to spend renovation money first, and it's the subject of our piece on why a rating won't tell you what to fix first. The star rating on its own compresses all that zone-level detail into a single figure, which is convenient for comparing listings but nearly useless for triage.

Whilst you're at it, check which climate zone file the assessment used. It's usually printed on the certificate as a location or climate zone code, and it drives every load calculation in the model. Get that wrong (a common issue on properties near zone boundaries) and every other number on the page is built on a shaky assumption. We've covered that specific failure mode in what a rating actually assumes about your climate file.

What to actually ask your assessor for

If you're commissioning a new assessment, ask upfront for the full software output alongside the certificate, not just the summary page. If you're buying a house with an existing rating and want to know what's really in the walls, contact the original assessor (their accreditation number is on the certificate) and request the Construction Details Report or equivalent. Most will provide it for a small fee or sometimes for free if you're the homeowner of record. For US buyers, RESNET maintains a rater directory through its national registry, which is a legitimate first stop if you can't track down the original rater, and the Department of Energy's Energy Star New Homes program has plain-language guidance on how a HERS Index Score is built up from underlying assembly data.

None of this is complicated once you know it exists, it's just not information either scheme volunteers by default. I'd rather see both NatHERS and RESNET require the assembly-level detail be issued as standard alongside every certificate. Until that changes, the honest move is to ask for it yourself, before you sign off on a build or put in an offer on a place that's spruiking its star rating on the listing.

For the bigger picture on where insulation and glazing choices sit against your other electrification decisions, our green building hub is a reasonable starting point, and Electrification 101 covers where a rating fits if you're only doing one upgrade at a time.

— Ben Sorensen, Green Building

Tagged

Common questions

Does a NatHERS certificate ever include R-values?
Not on the standard certificate. The star rating and load figures are the summary output; R-values and U-values live in the assessor's underlying software file, which you need to request separately as a Construction Details Report or the raw assessment file.
Can I get the backup data for a HERS rating on a US home?
Yes, ask the rater for the Rating Data Report from their REM/Rate or Ekotrope software. It lists individual assembly R-values, window specs and any blower door or duct leakage test results, none of which appear on the summary HERS Index certificate.
If the certificate doesn't list R-values, how do I know the insulation was actually installed as specified?
You generally can't confirm this from the certificate alone. A blower door test or thermal imaging inspection after installation is the more reliable way to check that what's in the walls matches what was modelled.
Why doesn't the rating body just require R-values on every certificate?
R-values in isolation can mislead without assembly context, like framing type or thermal bridging, and the certificate is designed as a compliance artefact for a specific point in the design and permit process, not a construction verification document.
About the author
BS
Ben Sorensen
Green building · Perth, AU

Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.

Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).

More from Ben Sorensen