Why a NatHERS or HERS rating can't tell you two houses feel different

By Ben Sorensen · November 2, 2026 · 7 min read
Attic space with insulation and skylights
Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash

I had a client in Daylesford a few months back who was convinced her assessor had made a mistake. Her new build came in at 7.2 stars, same as her sister's place across town, built the same year by a different crew. "They should feel the same," she said. They don't. Her sister's living room holds its temperature like a thermos. Hers swings five degrees between 7am and 3pm on a sunny winter day, even with the same rating stapled to both certificates.

She wasn't wrong to be annoyed, but she was asking the wrong question. A NatHERS or HERS rating was never built to predict how a room feels against your skin. It predicts modelled annual heating and cooling energy load, averaged across the whole dwelling, against a reference climate file. Comfort and energy load correlate, loosely, but they are not the same measurement, and the gap between them is where a lot of post-handover disappointment lives.

What the star rating is actually scoring

The simulation software behind a NatHERS or HERS certificate, whether that's AccuRate, FirstRate5 or BERS Pro on the Australian side, runs an hour-by-hour thermal model of the building envelope against a full year of climate data for your zone. It outputs a predicted number of megajoules per square metre needed to keep the home within a set temperature band. That number gets converted to stars. It's a single metric, built for comparing designs, not a lived-experience forecast.

Here's the part that catches people out: the software averages conditioned zones. It doesn't care if your hallway runs two degrees colder than your bedroom provided the home-wide number balances out. I've written before about how a NatHERS or HERS rating treats every room as equal, and the comfort-feel question is really an extension of that same blind spot. Two houses can hit identical whole-house averages while one has a thermal dead zone the other doesn't.

Mass, not just resistance, changes how a room feels

This is the bit I keep coming back to on site. Thermal mass, think a concrete slab, dense brick veneer, or a masonry internal wall, doesn't dramatically change your star rating in most climate zones compared to lightweight construction with equivalent insulation. But it changes how the house feels enormously. Mass smooths out the swing. It absorbs daytime heat gain and releases it slowly overnight, so the temperature graph looks like a gentle wave instead of a spike. A lightweight timber-framed house with great insulation can score the same stars as a heavier masonry build, because the software is scoring annual energy load, not the rate of temperature change within a day. If you're the kind of household that's home during the day and sensitive to swings, that distinction matters more than the certificate number ever will.

I'll admit I underweighted this for years myself, treating R-values as the whole story. They're not. Mass placement, especially internal mass exposed to the living areas rather than buried behind plasterboard, does work the simulation doesn't fully reward.

Glazing orientation gets modelled, but gain timing doesn't always match life

I've covered how the software's orientation assumptions can miss your actual site conditions in a separate piece on orientation, so I won't re-run that ground here. What's relevant to comfort specifically is timing. A west-facing living room with a large unshaded window might model fine on paper if the overall heating and cooling load balances against good insulation elsewhere in the house. But that room will spike in late afternoon in summer regardless of what the certificate says, because the simulation is distributing heat gain across a full day and a full year, and your actual afternoon in late January doesn't average out. It just happens. Shading, eave depth and glazing specification all factor into the model, but the model's output is a number, not a felt experience at 4:30pm on a 38-degree day.

Air movement and stuffiness sit mostly outside the rating

NatHERS and HERS modelling accounts for infiltration (unwanted air leakage) as a fixed assumption, usually a reasonably conservative default unless you've had an actual blower door test done, which almost nobody does at design stage. What it doesn't model well is deliberate ventilation design: cross-breeze paths, high-low openings, ceiling fan placement, the stuff that makes a well-designed room feel fresh in shoulder seasons without running any mechanical system at all. A house can score strongly on paper and still feel stuffy if the window layout doesn't actually let air move through it. I'd argue this is one of the most underrated design levers in Australian housing right now; it costs little at design stage and gets skipped constantly because it doesn't show up as a number on the certificate.

If you want a sense of how far the assessor's own on-site checks extend beyond the model, that's covered in what a home energy assessor actually measures on site. Short version: quite a lot gets checked, but airflow design intent generally isn't part of it. For the technical baseline on how Australian residential modelling tools handle these inputs, the NatHERS website publishes the software accreditation protocol if you want to go deeper than I'm going here.

Where occupancy assumptions widen the gap further

Every simulation runs on standardised occupancy and usage assumptions, fixed internal temperature setpoints, typical appliance heat loads, a generic household schedule. I've written separately about what the rating assumes about how you'll actually live in the house, and it's worth reading alongside this one because the two issues compound each other. A retiree home-all-day household in a 7-star house built on lightweight construction with west glazing is going to feel that house very differently to a family who's out from 7am to 6pm on weekdays. The certificate doesn't know which household you are. It can't.

This is also why two assessors modelling the same design can land on different numbers depending on how defaults get applied, something I went into in why the same house can get two different star ratings. Small input variations compound through an hour-by-hour annual simulation in ways that aren't always intuitive.

So what should you actually check, beyond the number

If you're building or buying and comfort matters to you as much as the energy bill, ask your designer three things the star rating won't answer: where is the thermal mass relative to the living areas, what's the actual eave and shading detail on west and north glazing (not just the glazing spec), and is there a genuine cross-ventilation path through the main living zone. None of these show up as a line item on a NatHERS or HERS certificate. All three shape how the house feels on the specific hot afternoon or cold morning you're actually standing in it. A hot water heat pump and a well-sized ducted system, products like the Voltex MAX hybrid heat pump water heater or a Daikin Premium Inverter Ducted system, will still do useful work regardless of envelope quality. But a good envelope means those systems run less, cycle less, and last longer, which is really the point of the whole exercise.

Worth noting too: the US HERS Index, administered through RESNET, works on a similar logic to NatHERS, lower index score equals better projected performance against a reference home, with the same structural gap between modelled energy load and felt comfort. The fundamentals translate across both systems even though the scoring mechanics differ.

The certificate is a planning tool, use it as one

None of this means the star rating is useless, far from it. It's a genuinely good comparative tool for evaluating design options before a slab gets poured, and I've made the case elsewhere that it's best understood as a design tool rather than a build receipt. The mistake is expecting it to promise a feeling. It promises a modelled load. Those two things usually move in the same direction, which is exactly why the gap catches people out when they don't.

If you're deciding between two near-identical star ratings on paper, ask to see the shading diagrams and the internal mass layout before you ask to see the number again. That's where the real difference between a house that scores well and a house that feels good gets decided.

— Ben Sorensen, Green Building, IceWarm

Tagged

Common questions

Can two houses with the same NatHERS or HERS star rating feel completely different to live in?
Yes, routinely. The rating scores modelled annual heating and cooling energy load for the whole dwelling, not room-by-room temperature swings, thermal mass placement, airflow design or occupancy patterns, all of which shape how a space actually feels.
Does thermal mass affect my star rating the same way it affects comfort?
Not proportionally. Mass like a concrete slab or masonry wall smooths daily temperature swings noticeably in lived experience, but its effect on the annual energy load number the rating produces is often modest compared to insulation and glazing changes.
Should I ask my designer for anything beyond the star rating number?
Ask about thermal mass placement relative to living areas, actual shading detail on west and north glazing, and whether there's a genuine cross-ventilation path. None of these are visible on the certificate itself.
Is the US HERS Index measuring the same thing as Australia's NatHERS?
Broadly similar logic, a lower HERS Index score means better projected performance against a reference home, but it shares the same structural gap between modelled energy load and felt comfort that NatHERS has.
About the author
BS
Ben Sorensen
Green building · Perth, AU

Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.

Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).

More from Ben Sorensen