Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never checks your windows' install

By Ben Sorensen · October 27, 2026 · 8 min read
Modern energy-efficient home exterior
Photo by Naksha Banwao on Unsplash

I was on site at a renovation off Hyde Street in Footscray a few months back, watching a glazier fit a double-glazed unit into a reveal that was, by my tape measure, about 4mm out of square on one corner. The window itself was a good one — low-E glass, a thermally broken frame, the kind of spec that reads nicely on a glazing schedule. The NatHERS assessment for that job had already been done months earlier, based on that exact spec. Nobody was coming back to check whether the frame sat flush, whether the flashing lapped correctly over the sill, or whether the gap around the frame got filled with compressible foam or just left to the plasterer's discretion. That's the bit I want to unpack, because it trips up more owners than almost anything else in the build process.

A home energy rating — NatHERS in Australia, HERS in the US — assesses a window as a product. The software takes the frame material, the glass type, the U-value and SHGC (solar heat gain coefficient) you've nominated, plugs those numbers into a thermal model, and calculates how that opening performs across a full year of simulated weather. What it does not do, and structurally cannot do from a desktop assessment, is confirm that the window as specified is the window as installed.

What the rating actually models

NatHERS works from a nominated performance figure for each window — usually a WERS (Window Energy Rating Scheme) rating or a manufacturer-supplied U-value and SHGC pair. HERS, through RESNET's modelling protocol in the US, works similarly off NFRC-rated assembly values. Either way, the assessor is entering a number that describes the window as a factory-tested assembly: glass plus frame plus any spacer bar, tested under controlled conditions.

That number assumes the window is installed the way the manufacturer's installation instructions describe — square in the opening, properly flashed, with the frame gap filled with an appropriate sealant or insulation rather than left as an air gap. It has to assume this, because the alternative is assessors attending every site twice: once at frame stage and once at lock-up, which isn't how the system is built or funded. I've written before about what your assessor actually measures on site, and window installation quality sits squarely in the "not checked" category alongside insulation batts and ductwork.

The gap between spec and installed performance

A poorly installed window doesn't just lose a little performance at the edges. A gap around the frame that isn't sealed properly becomes a direct air leakage path, and air leakage bypasses the insulating value of the glass entirely. You can have a window rated at a very respectable U-value and still have a draught running straight through the reveal because the installer used a bead of builder's caulk instead of a proper air seal, or because the frame was never packed out evenly and there's a 6mm void behind the architrave on one side.

Thermal bridging is the other sneaky one. Metal window frames, even thermally broken ones, can bridge badly if the surrounding wall insulation isn't dressed in neatly around the frame reveal. I've seen batts stop short of the window opening by 50-100mm because it's fiddly to cut and fit insulation tight to a frame, and that gap doesn't show up on any certificate. It shows up as a cold patch on a thermal camera, which is exactly the kind of thing a blower door and thermal imaging audit catches and a NatHERS assessment never will.

Why the rating can't close this gap

I don't think this is a flaw in the rating tools so much as a mismatch between what they're designed to do and what people assume they do. NatHERS and HERS are compliance and design tools, calculating a predicted energy outcome from a set of specified inputs. I've made this argument before about the system more broadly — it's a design tool, not a build receipt — and window installation is maybe the cleanest example of that distinction in practice.

To actually verify installation quality you need someone standing in the opening with a square, a moisture meter, and ideally a blower door test after lock-up. That's a different trade skill and a different inspection regime entirely. In Australia, window installation is meant to follow AS 2047 (windows in buildings) and the manufacturer's specific installation instructions, but compliance with that standard is checked, if at all, by a building surveyor or private certifier doing a stage inspection — not by the person who ran the thermal model six months prior. In the US, proper flashing and air sealing around window openings falls under the water-resistive barrier and air-barrier provisions of the International Residential Code, enforced by local building inspectors, again a completely separate process from the HERS rater's energy model.

Here's my honestly slightly contrarian take: I reckon most owners would get more real-world comfort improvement from paying a good glazier $500 extra to get the install right than from upgrading one grade of glass spec. Nobody markets it that way because installation quality doesn't show up on a product brochure, but it's the difference between a window performing to its rated number and a window performing 20-30% worse because of air leakage nobody measured.

What actually gets checked at stage inspections (and what doesn't)

Depending on your state or local jurisdiction, a frame-stage building inspection might glance at window openings for structural fixing — are the fasteners through the frame into structural timber or steel, is the opening the right size. It's rarely assessing thermal performance of the installation itself unless the inspector happens to be unusually diligent or the project has a specific performance pathway attached, like a Passive House certification process, which does include air-tightness testing as a mandatory step. For a standard volume-build or renovation under NatHERS or a standard HERS rating pathway, there's no equivalent checkpoint. The rating gets lodged, the certificate gets issued, and the actual quality of every window, door and penetration seal in the house is left to the trade's own standard of care and whatever the builder's supervisor happens to notice walking the site.

This is part of why I keep telling people the certificate is a ceiling on performance, not a guarantee of it. It describes what the house could achieve if every element was installed to spec. Whether it actually gets there depends on trade quality, supervision, and a fair bit of luck with which crew turns up that week.

What you can actually check yourself

If you're mid-build or just moved into a new place, there are a few things worth doing that cost nothing but time. Run your hand around the internal window reveals on a cold or windy day — if you can feel air movement, that's a sealing problem, not a glass problem. Look at the external flashing above each window if you can access it; it should lap over the cladding below it, not under, or water tracks straight into the wall cavity over time. And if you've got any sense the insulation wasn't dressed in properly around a frame, a cheap infrared thermometer pointed at the wall near the window reveal on a cold evening will show you a temperature difference compared to the clear wall area nearby, even without a full thermal camera.

None of this appears on your NatHERS certificate and none of it will. If you want that level of verification, you're looking at a dedicated blower door test, not a rating document. For context on how the rating treats the broader envelope, it's worth reading how small junction details get skipped in the modelling generally — windows are just the most visible version of that pattern because they're the one building element every occupant interacts with daily.

The practical takeaway for renovators

If you're commissioning new glazing, ask your installer directly whether they follow the manufacturer's installation instructions to the letter, including backing rod and sealant type, packer placement, and flashing sequence. A good glazier will have an answer ready. One who shrugs or says "we've always done it this way" is a flag worth noting before you sign off on the job, not after you've moved in and noticed a draught every winter.

It's also worth checking who's actually doing the glazing work if you're doing a reglaze or a window replacement rather than new construction — the licensing and quality checks differ from a full install, and I've gone through what to ask in vetting a double glazing repair or reglazing tradesman. The Australian Clean Energy Council and the US Department of Energy's building envelope guidance both publish installation best-practice material aimed at trades, and it's genuinely worth a homeowner's five minutes to skim, if only to know what questions to ask.

The rating did its job. It told the designer what glass spec would get the house across the line on paper. Whether that glass performs as modelled is a separate question, answered on site, by a trade, on a day nobody from the rating scheme will ever visit.

— Ben Sorensen, Green Building writer, IceWarm

Tagged

Common questions

Does NatHERS or HERS require an inspection of window installation quality?
No. Both systems model the performance rating you nominate for the window product (U-value, SHGC, or WERS/NFRC rating) and assume it's installed to the manufacturer's instructions. Neither NatHERS assessors nor HERS raters routinely inspect flashing, sealing or frame alignment on site as part of the rating itself.
Who actually checks that windows are installed correctly?
In Australia this falls to the building surveyor or private certifier at stage inspections, where it exists, and ultimately to the installer's own standard of care against AS 2047 and the manufacturer's instructions. In the US it's the local building inspector checking against the International Residential Code's water-resistive barrier and flashing provisions. Neither process is tied to the HERS rating.
Can bad window installation actually undo a good glazing spec?
Yes, often significantly. Air leakage around an improperly sealed frame bypasses the insulating value of the glass entirely, and gaps in surrounding wall insulation create thermal bridging that a rated U-value doesn't capture. A blower door test or thermal imaging audit is the practical way to catch this, not the energy rating certificate.
What should I ask a glazier before they install new windows?
Ask whether they follow the specific manufacturer's installation instructions for backing rod, sealant type, packer placement and flashing sequence, and whether they're familiar with AS 2047 in Australia or equivalent IRC flashing provisions in the US. A confident, specific answer is a good sign; vague reassurance isn't.
About the author
BS
Ben Sorensen
Green building · Perth, AU

Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.

Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).

More from Ben Sorensen