What your NatHERS or HERS assessor actually measures on site
I sat in on a site assessment in Brunswick a few months back, a double-fronted Edwardian the owners were extending. The assessor was in and out in under forty minutes. He didn't open a single cupboard, didn't check the hot water system, didn't ask what heater they used. He measured window reveals, photographed the roof space insulation from a manhole, and left. The owner looked a bit deflated afterwards. "Is that it?" she asked me. Fair question, and one I get a lot.
People assume a home energy rating assessment is something like a building inspection: thorough, forensic, covering everything that could possibly matter to comfort or running costs. It isn't, and understanding exactly what gets measured, versus what gets assumed, skipped or taken on the architect's word, changes how you use the result. I've written before about why a rating won't tell you what to fix first and why the certificate doesn't list a single R-value. This piece is the companion to those: a walk-through of the actual site checklist, what's measured with a tool versus eyeballed, and where the gaps sit.
The focus keyword here: NatHERS site inspection
A NatHERS site inspection, or the equivalent HERS verification visit in the US, exists for one purpose: to confirm the thermal performance inputs already modelled in the software match what's actually been built, or what's actually proposed in the drawings. It is a verification exercise against a model, not an open-ended audit of the house's energy performance. That distinction matters because it explains almost every "why didn't they check that" question homeowners ask afterwards.
For new builds and major renovations, the first rating usually happens at design stage, off plans, before a assessor ever sets foot on site. The on-site visit, where one happens at all, is typically a compliance check after construction, confirming insulation was installed as specified and glazing matches the schedule. For existing-home ratings, which are becoming more common off the back of state-level disclosure schemes, the site visit is the primary data-gathering event.
What gets measured with an instrument
Three things get measured, not estimated, on a typical visit. Window and door dimensions get a tape measure or laser rangefinder, because glazing area as a percentage of floor area is one of the heaviest-weighted inputs in the whole model. Wall and ceiling heights get measured the same way, feeding directly into room volumes. And insulation thickness, where it's visible through a manhole or wall cavity inspection point, gets measured with a ruler against the batt or blanket, not assumed from the product name on the packaging.
That third one surprises people. An assessor won't take "R4 batts" written on a box as gospel if the batts visible through the manhole look compressed or patchy. I've seen assessors photograph insulation from four angles specifically because what's written on packaging and what's actually sitting in the ceiling cavity after a few trades have walked through it are not always the same thing. This is the same gap I covered in the piece on small junction details — the model assumes continuous coverage, the ceiling space tells a different story.
What gets checked visually, no tool required
A lot of what feeds the model is logged by eye against a checklist, not measured. Construction type of external walls — brick veneer, weatherboard, rendered block — gets confirmed visually because it determines the thermal mass assumption baked into the simulation. Window frame material, aluminium versus timber versus uPVC, gets noted the same way, because frame conductivity changes the whole-of-window U-value used in the model even when the glass itself is identical. Roof colour gets checked too, surprisingly literally, because solar absorptance assumptions shift between light and dark roofing and that changes the modelled cooling load. Shading structures, eaves depth, pergolas, neighbouring buildings that cast shadow, all get visually assessed against the drawings rather than measured with precision instruments.
None of this requires a blower door or thermal camera. That's a different, separate trade entirely, and if you want actual air leakage data you need a blower door and thermal imaging auditor, not a NatHERS assessor. The two get conflated constantly and it's worth being clear they're not the same service.
What the assessor almost never touches
Here's where I'll offer an opinion that I don't think the industry says loudly enough: the gap between what gets assessed and what homeowners assume gets assessed is, in my view, the single biggest source of post-rating disappointment. The assessor generally won't check your actual heating and cooling appliance, because the model uses a generic reference appliance efficiency, not whatever split system or heat pump you end up installing. They won't check ductwork condition or sealing, a gap I've covered at length in the ductwork piece. They won't check draught sealing around skirting boards, door frames or downlights unless it happens to be visible and obviously wrong. And they almost never check actual air leakage rates, because that requires a blower door test, which sits outside the standard assessment scope and cost. They also won't ask how you intend to use the house. Whether you run the heater at 18°C or 23°C, whether you open windows at night in summer, whether you've got three teenagers taking long hot showers, none of it enters the model. That's deliberate, and I've written separately about what the rating assumes about how you'll actually live in the house.
Why the assessor's climate zone and orientation data matter more than you'd think
Two inputs get locked in early and rarely revisited on site: the climate file for your postcode, and the building's orientation relative to true north. Get the orientation wrong on the plans, even by 20 or 30 degrees, and the modelled heating and cooling loads shift meaningfully without a single physical change to the house. I covered the mechanics of that in the azimuth versus magnetic north piece for solar, and the same compass error trips up building orientation data feeding into the thermal model, as explained in why NatHERS and HERS ratings handle orientation the way they do. An assessor checking an existing structure will usually confirm orientation with a compass or site survey document rather than relying purely on the architect's north-point arrow, which is good practice, but it's not universal. If you're having a rating done and nobody mentions checking the compass bearing against the plans, it's a fair question to ask.
Construction documentation versus what's actually on site
For a new build, a huge amount of what an assessor records at design stage lives in construction specification documents: wall systems, insulation batts specified per AS/NZS 4859.1 for thermal insulation materials, glazing performance data from the window manufacturer, floor construction type. The site visit, when it happens, exists to cross-check these specifications against built reality. This is where things go sideways most often in my experience. A builder substitutes a cheaper window system mid-construction, or an insulation installer runs out of R4 batts and finishes a section with R3.5 because that's what was on the truck that day. Neither change necessarily gets flagged back to the original assessor unless someone commissions a formal as-built re-rating. The original certificate, in that case, describes a house that doesn't quite exist. The US HERS process, overseen by RESNET's verification protocol, builds in a bit more rigour here through mandatory on-site inspection at multiple construction stages for a formal HERS Index score, which is one structural difference worth knowing if you're comparing the two systems.
What this means when you're commissioning a rating
If you're paying for a rating, existing-home or new-build, ask specifically what the site visit will and won't cover before the assessor turns up. Ask whether insulation will be physically measured or taken on trust from packaging. Ask whether window U-values come from manufacturer data sheets or from a generic default table, because the gap between the two can be sizeable on a close call. And treat the resulting star rating, or HERS Index number, as a design-stage comparison tool rather than a guarantee of comfort. I made that argument properly in the design-tool-not-a-build-receipt piece, and the site inspection process is really the mechanical proof of why that framing holds. A good assessor is thorough within a narrow, defined scope. They are not auditing your comfort, your bills, or your actual lived experience of the house, and honestly, I don't think they ever claimed to.
If you want the broader context on how these ratings fit into a renovation or build, our green building hub has the rest of this series, and it's worth reading before you book an assessor rather than after.
— Ben Sorensen, Green Building Writer, IceWarm
Common questions
- Does a NatHERS or HERS assessor check my heating and cooling system?
- No. The thermal model uses a generic reference appliance efficiency rather than the actual unit you install, so your heat pump brand, size or COP has no bearing on the star rating or HERS Index number.
- Will the assessor test for draughts or air leakage?
- Generally not. Standard NatHERS and HERS assessments don't include blower door testing. That's a separate service from a dedicated energy auditor, and it measures something the standard rating simply doesn't capture.
- Can I ask to see how my insulation was measured?
- Yes, and you should. A thorough assessor measures batt thickness against a ruler through a manhole or inspection point rather than relying on packaging descriptions, and it's reasonable to ask which method they used on your house.
- Why does my rating change if nothing about the house changed?
- Inputs like the climate file, software version, or even a corrected orientation reading can shift the modelled result without any physical work happening. That's a separate issue covered in our piece on why star ratings can change without touching the house.
Ben covers insulation, glazing and home energy ratings — the building-envelope work that decides how hard every other system has to work.
Building-certification background (NatHERS-adjacent).
More from Ben Sorensen
- Why a NatHERS or HERS rating can change without touching the buildA NatHERS or HERS rating can shift star bands when software updates, climate files get revised, or rules change — even if your house hasn't.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating ignores your floor coveringsCarpet, tile and polished concrete all score the same in a NatHERS or HERS model, even though they feel wildly different underfoot and change how your heating actually performs.
- Vetting an insulation installer: the R-value receipt nobody asks forInsulation installers rarely need a specific trade licence, which is exactly why the paperwork trail matters more than the handshake.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never touches your thermal bridgesA NatHERS or HERS rating models your walls as flat layers, which means steel studs, balcony slabs and window reveals rarely get the credit (or blame) they deserve.
- Why your NatHERS or HERS rating never checks your orientation on siteYour NatHERS or HERS star rating locks in orientation at design stage, but nobody re-checks it once the slab is poured the wrong way round.
- Vetting a window glazier for new-build glazing: what to checkBefore a glazier touches your new-build windows, check the licence, the AS 2047 compliance paperwork and the install method. Here's what actually matters.